Episode 24: The Charlatan and the Magus, with Lionel Snell
Aug 28, 2018
auto_awesome
Lionel Snell, a.k.a. Ramsey Dukes, is an author and esoteric thinker exploring the intersections of magic and philosophy. He dives into the roles of trickery and authenticity in spiritual practices, challenging conventional views on truth and illusion. Snell discusses the wisdom found in deceitful experiences, cultural shifts in perceptions of truth, and the balance between rational thought and magical belief. He champions embracing uncertainty and mystery, ultimately advocating for a richer understanding of reality that transcends strict rationalism.
Trickery may serve as a vital catalyst in experiencing real magic, challenging the conventional view of magic as merely fraudulent.
Dukes invites a cyclical understanding of cultural paradigms, emphasizing the importance of rebalancing truth, beauty, and goodness in our experiences.
Deep dives
The Intersection of Magic and Skepticism
The discussion highlights the paradoxical relationship between perceived fraud and genuine magic, as outlined by Ramsey Dukes. He points out that when examples of charlatans and exploitative gurus come to light, people typically respond in one of three ways: skeptics dismiss all magic as fraudulent, defensive believers feel attacked, and committed believers defend their truth against the frauds. Dukes proposes a different lens through which to view this dynamic, suggesting that trickery may not be a flaw but rather an integral part of the magical experience. By positioning charlatans and magi as potentially the same entity, he invites listeners to explore trickery's role in the journey toward understanding magic.
The Role of Trickery in Authentic Experiences
The podcast emphasizes that trickery is a necessary catalyst for experiencing real magic, positing that genuine effects can emerge from the practice of deception. Dukes compares this notion to the idea of 'fake it till you make it,' illustrating how by embracing trickery, individuals might cultivate genuine magical experiences. The application of this principle is akin to a form of playfulness that opens up potentialities and allows individuals to explore their beliefs without immediately succumbing to rational skepticism. Thus, the necessity of trickery serves to enhance mystical encounters, suggesting that authentic magic often arises from playful experimentation.
Cyclical Nature of Cultural Thought
The conversation addresses the evolving relationship between different cultural paradigms such as magic, art, religion, and science, and how these cultural beliefs cycle through dominance over time. Dukes critiques the linear understanding of cultural progress, suggesting instead that each cultural phase—whether it be scientific or magical—has its own value and relevance. He notes that the current cultural moment is one of disillusionment with strict rationalism, hinting at a potential resurgence of magical thinking and spiritual inquiry. This cyclical perspective recognizes that disorder and disruption can pave the way for new forms of understanding and experience to emerge.
Rethinking Truth, Beauty, and Goodness
Dukes underscores the importance of rebalancing values such as truth, beauty, and goodness in contemporary society, arguing that an over-reliance on truth leads to a narrow understanding of reality. He uses examples like art and healing to illustrate how beauty and goodness can and should be emphasized more in our assessments of experiences. By exploring these transcendentals, individuals can embrace a more wholistic understanding of their experiences, acknowledging that magical and transformative moments can arise from the interplay between these values. This framework fosters a more enriching engagement with life, inviting openness to the unexpected elements of our reality.
As Lionel Snell, also known as Ramsey Dukes, observes in his seminal esoteric essay, "The Charlatan and the Magus" (1984), the series of trumps in a tarot deck doesn't begin with the noble Emperor or august Hierophant, but with the lowly Fool, followed by the Juggler. Trickery or illusion, Snell suggests, may not be the dealbreaker we've thought it to be in parapsychological investigation. It may even be a feature, not a bug, of the magical process. In this episode of Weird Studies, JF and Phil talk to Lionel Snell about trickster magic, and all we miss out on when we make rational truth the only measure by which we know reality.