Is the Fed Done Raising Rates? Ellen Zentner Thinks So
Sep 22, 2023
auto_awesome
Morgan Stanley Chief US Economist Ellen Zentner predicts the Fed is done raising rates, citing cooling inflation. A potential government shutdown by Republicans could further justify maintaining the status quo at the November meeting. Uncertainty and lack of data hinder monetary-policy making. The podcast also discusses the challenges of predicting economic developments, analyzing real interest rates' impact on the economy, and the potential effects of the UAW strike.
The US Federal Reserve is likely done raising interest rates, but the possibility of a government shutdown could lead to policy paralysis in decision-making about rate paths.
Ellen Zentner predicts a 40% probability of a recession within the next 12 months, highlighting uncertainties and risks ahead despite the current momentum in the economy for the next six months.
Deep dives
Fed Meeting and Market Reaction
The Federal Reserve opted not to raise interest rates at their recent meeting, but the markets reacted negatively to the projections indicating a less aggressive rate cut next year. This led to a sell-off in both stocks and bonds, with the 10-year treasury yield reaching its highest level since 2007. The statement was seen as more hawkish than expected, with a focus on jobs remaining strong and inflation remaining robust. The Fed's intention to achieve a soft landing for the economy was met with market apprehension.
The Impact of Government Shutdown
The potential for a government shutdown in September further clouds the economic outlook. A full government shutdown would mean a lack of official data for the Federal Reserve to make decisions on interest rates. Additionally, each week of a shutdown is estimated to shave off about 0.2 percentage points from GDP growth. While past shutdowns have had temporary impacts, any prolonged shutdown could have lasting effects on the economy.
Oil Price Shock and Consumer Impact
The recent increase in oil prices poses both risks and benefits to the economy. While a supply-driven increase in oil prices may have a muted impact on inflation, it acts as a tax on consumers who have to pay more for gas. This can reduce consumer buying power and slow down real income growth and consumer spending. Sustained higher oil prices could pose a risk to inflation expectations and have a larger impact on the economy.
Economic Uncertainty and Soft Landing
The economist Ellen Zentner discusses the challenges of forecasting in the current economic climate. The past few years have been unpredictable, with major disruptions followed by massive stimulus. Zentner emphasizes the need for creative thinking and analysis to navigate the outlook. While she sees enough momentum in the economy for the next six months, she maintains a 40% probability of a recession within the next 12 months, highlighting uncertainties and risks ahead.
When it comes to the US Federal Reserve’s campaign to crush inflation by raising interest rates, Morgan Stanley Chief US Economist Ellen Zentner says this: “I have a strong view that they’re done here—but they have left the door open.”
Zentner joined the What Goes Up podcast to discuss the Fed’s decision this week to pause rate hikes, and what she expects of monetary policy and the US economy going forward. Cooling inflation should keep the central bank on hold until it’s ready to cut rates next year, she says. In the near term, a potential government shutdown by Republicans would bolster the case for maintaining the status quo at the Fed’s November meeting. A shutdown, she explains, would leave policymakers without all of the economic data they need to make a decision.
“In monetary-policy making, uncertainty tends to lead to policy paralysis,” Zentner says. “If we’re lacking data that the Fed can officially sink its teeth into, then that’s going to lead to an inability to make a decision about the path for rates.”