Protesting Tesla Can Hurt Elon Musk w/ Ed Niedermeyer
Feb 27, 2025
auto_awesome
Ed Niedermeyer, author of "Ludicrous: The Unvarnished Story of Tesla Motors," discusses the complexities of Tesla's business model and Elon Musk's significant influence on both the automotive industry and U.S. politics. He highlights the vulnerabilities of Musk's power in the face of protests and the challenge of maintaining Tesla's market position amid rising competition. Niedermeyer also critiques the gap between Musk's ambitious hype and Tesla's realities, urging collective action to address corporate dominance and reshape the narrative around the EV landscape.
Elon Musk's power is increasingly tied to his political connections, raising concerns about the merger of corporate interests and governance.
Tesla's business model struggles due to stagnation in new vehicle models and intensified competition, jeopardizing its market share and profitability.
Grassroots protests aimed at undermining Tesla's revenue represent a strategic push for accountability within the tech industry and challenge Musk's influence.
Deep dives
Elon Musk's Influence on Government
Elon Musk has positioned himself at the center of the American government, mirroring his influence over Tesla and Twitter. His interactions with government figures, including public appearances alongside Donald Trump, reveal a troubling convergence of business and politics. This situation raises concerns about the implications of such power dynamics, as Musk has effectively leveraged his wealth and influence to maneuver within government spaces. Observers note that this shift not only affects the electric vehicle market but also signals deeper issues regarding the intertwining of corporate interests and political authority.
Tesla's Struggling Business Model
Tesla's business is currently facing significant challenges, with a lack of new models and declining sales figures contributing to a precarious situation. The company's overreliance on established models like the Model 3 and Model Y has led to stagnation, and the anticipated Cybertruck has not generated the expected consumer interest. The brand has transitioned from a pioneering electric vehicle maker to becoming more of a luxury niche manufacturer, missing opportunities to create affordable options for a broader market. As the competition intensifies, particularly from Chinese automakers, Tesla's profitability and market share are increasingly at risk.
The Psychological Toll on Investors
Tesla's share price remains tethered to the public perception of Elon Musk rather than the company's fundamental performance, illustrating the psychological nature of investing in stocks. Musk's continued promises around self-driving technology and ambitious ventures have created a speculative environment, allowing investors to maintain confidence despite the company’s challenges. However, as skepticism grows regarding these promises, the stock's volatility could lead to a significant sell-off if investors perceive that the business is deteriorating. This highlights the precarious nature of Tesla's market position, where confidence can quickly shift to fear among its investor base.
The Power of Collective Action
Amidst uncertainties surrounding Tesla and Musk's influence, there is a call for collective grassroots actions aimed at challenging this power structure. Strategies include organized protests at Tesla dealerships to raise awareness of the potential consequences of supporting the company and its CEO. The overarching goal is to cripple Tesla's revenue, which would further expose its vulnerabilities and erode investor confidence in the stock. Encouraging communities to engage in visible acts of solidarity may serve as a catalyst for broader movements seeking accountability within the tech industry.
Reframing the Narrative Around EVs
The ongoing discourse surrounding Tesla has highlighted the need to rethink the narrative around electric vehicles and their role in the market. As traditional automakers develop competitive electric models, the idea that Tesla is the sole champion for EVs is increasingly challenged. Activists argue that the environmental and social implications of supporting Tesla warrant a reevaluation of where consumers direct their investments. The belief that one brand can single-handedly address the transition to electric mobility is fading, revealing a landscape where multiple players are emerging to offer viable alternatives.
Paris Marx is joined by Ed Niedermeyer to discuss the trouble with Tesla’s business model and how that makes Elon Musk’s power vulnerable to protest and boycott.
Ed Niedermeyer is the author Ludicrous: The Unvarnished Story of Tesla Motors and a co-host of the Autonocast.
Tech Won’t Save Us offers a critical perspective on tech, its worldview, and wider society with the goal of inspiring people to demand better tech and a better world. Support the show on Patreon.
The podcast is made in partnership with The Nation. Production is by Eric Wickham.