Dr. Gwen Adshead, a forensic psychiatrist with nearly 40 years at renowned institutions like Broadmoor, investigates the complex nature of violence. She ponder whether violence is a natural human trait and explores the deep-rooted links between trauma and aggressive behavior. The discussion delves into the psychological factors that drive individuals to violence and examines the role of restorative justice in healing both victims and offenders. Insights from her therapeutic experiences provide a compassionate perspective on this often misunderstood issue.
Dr. Gwen Adshead argues that while violence may not be entirely unnatural, it should not be perceived as normal behavior within society.
Understanding the diverse backgrounds of violent offenders reveals that addressing emotional distress and societal factors is crucial for preventing future violence.
Deep dives
Understanding the Nature of Violence
The episode delves into the complex question of whether violence is a normal part of human behavior. Research indicates that while violence exists in primate communities, understanding its context reveals that even such animals adhere to social rules regarding its use. This suggests that although violence may not be entirely unnatural, it does not equate to being normal. The lecture discusses how humans might normalize violence due to a shared capacity for cruelty, leading to a distorted perception of violent behavior as an intrinsic trait rather than a complex societal issue.
The Individual Stories Behind Violence
The podcast emphasizes that there is no 'typical' perpetrator of violence, highlighting the diverse backgrounds and circumstances leading to violent acts. An examination of homicide statistics reveals that while UK rates are low, each incident profoundly impacts families and communities. Furthermore, individual cases illustrate that violent offenders often grapple with their actions and can be much like anyone else, drawing parallels between emotional distress and violent outcomes. By presenting real-life scenarios, the episode argues that understanding the personal narratives behind these actions is crucial for preventing future violence.
Complex Causes of Violent Behavior
The episode discusses the multiplicity of factors that can lead to violence, emphasizing that no single cause can explain why individuals resort to violence. Social determinants, including childhood experiences and external stressors, play significant roles in shaping behavior. Notably, events such as significant emotional triggers, including competitive scenarios or relationship tensions, can escalate into violence. This complexity underscores the importance of addressing broader societal issues and providing support rather than solely relying on punitive measures.
The Role of Mental Health in Violence
An exploration of mental health reveals that many individuals who commit violent acts may not fit a straightforward profile of 'madness' but often face profound emotional turmoil. The lecture contends that misconceptions about mental illness can lead to stigmatization and hinder effective preventative measures. Therapeutic interventions for both victims and perpetrators are highlighted as essential tools in understanding and mitigating future risks. Recognizing that even those deemed dangerous are often struggling with their humanity can foster a more compassionate and effective approach to violence reduction.
In her 2024 Reith Lectures, Dr Gwen Adshead, addresses four questions that she has most commonly faced in her work as a therapist with violent perpetrators in secure psychiatric units and prisons:
Is Violence normal?
What is the relationship between trauma and violence?
Is there such a thing as Evil?
Can we change violent minds?
In this first lecture, using data and real-life stories from nearly 40 years’ experience as a forensic Psychiatrist working inside institutions such as Broadmoor, she asks if violence is normal.
Is violence unnatural? Or is it normal because, deep down, we are all capable of cruelty and can experience, even briefly, the urge to hurt others? What then are the tipping points, what are the factors that drive some to kill?
The programme was recorded at Broadcasting House in London in front of an audience and is presented and chaired by Anita Anand.
Producer; Jim Frank
Editor: Clare Fordham
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode