Midweek: Hīkoi bias claims, Herald v Bain privacy, mag strife
Nov 20, 2024
auto_awesome
Accusations of media bias surround the coverage of a recent peaceful Hīkoi. Discussions reveal contrasting portrayals of protests and the challenges of journalistic impartiality. Controversy arises over the New Zealand Herald's handling of David Bain's privacy, raising questions about the protection of minors. The podcast also reflects on the struggles facing print media, highlighted by the closure of a notable magazine and efforts to combat rising digital scams, showcasing the evolving landscape of news reporting.
The media's portrayal of the Hīkoi mō Te Tiriti sparked debates over bias and consistency in coverage of protests across different contexts.
Controversies surrounding RNZ host Miki Ngarangi Forbes highlighted tensions around media impartiality and the complexities of maintaining objectivity in journalism.
Deep dives
Positive Coverage of Hikoi Mote Tiriti
The Hikoi Mote Tiriti featured prominently in media coverage, described as a historic and peaceful protest advocating for treaty principles. Major news outlets like the New Zealand Herald highlighted the event as a significant demonstration of democracy, showcasing extensive visuals and positive narratives surrounding the marchers' unity. This portrayal, however, sparked a debate over the media's sympathetic tone, especially in contrast to coverage of other protests that had a different context. Some commentators criticized this favorable approach as overly friendly or uncritical, raising questions about the consistency of media representations of protests across the political spectrum.
Impartiality and Media Standards Critique
Discussions surrounding media impartiality emerged prominently, particularly focused on the social media behavior of RNZ host Miki Ngarangi Forbes. Critics, including political correspondents, argued that her actions during the Hikoi breached RNZ's standards for impartiality, prompting calls for accountability from the broadcaster. Supporters of Forbes maintained that she was merely reporting and not participating in any political campaigning, emphasizing that posing for photos with various figures does not inherently imply bias. This controversy highlighted the ongoing tensions around perceived impartiality in the media, especially for public broadcasters funded by taxpayer money.
Media's Role and the Pursuit of Objectivity
A broader conversation regarding the media's role in society and the quest for objectivity versus impartiality unfolded, noting the complexity of achieving true neutrality. Journalists have a duty to report facts while also interpreting and providing context for stories, which may reflect personal biases, consciously or unconsciously. Leaders in the industry posited that the aim should not just be to record differing viewpoints but to present truth based on evidence while balancing varying perspectives. This raises essential questions about the nature of journalism: should media outlets strive for a theoretical objectivity, or should they openly acknowledge the biases inherent in their reporting?
Accusations of bias and a lack of impartiatality in coverage of Hīkoi mō Te Tiriti. Also the Herald v David Bain, Facebook scam surge and problems for local magazines.