
The Comedy Cellar: Live from the Table Philosopher Michael Walzer Has Not Changed His Mind About Israel
12 snips
Nov 12, 2026 Michael Walzer, a political philosopher and author of Just and Unjust Wars, discusses Hamas’s October 7 attack, civilian casualties, Israel’s military strategy, Netanyahu’s leadership, and the future of Palestinian self-determination. He rejects claims that he changed his position on Israel and argues for its survival. The conversation also explores media framing, intellectual conformity, accountability, and celebrity power.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Why Gaza’s Early Casualties Were So High
- Early civilian casualties rose because Israel changed its acceptable-loss ratio and relied on outdated information.
- Repeatedly retaking neighborhoods followed from clearing areas without enough manpower to capture and hold them.
Why Walzer Says He Never Changed His Mind
- The New Yorker headline framed Walzer as changing his mind, although he says the article concerned an academic debate predating the Gaza war.
- He used Allied bombing of Hamburg or Dresden to distinguish condemning war crimes from abandoning a just war.
When A Just War Becomes Unjust
- Walzer’s standard is not a fixed casualty threshold but whether military force remains necessary to achieve the war’s legitimate objective.
- He judged the war unjust when a credible Arab-European political route could defeat Hamas without continued killing.








