Neurosymbolic AI in Search with Professor Laura Dietz - Weaviate Podcast #49!
May 25, 2023
auto_awesome
Professor Laura Dietz discusses Neurosymbolic Search, Entity Linking, Entity Re-Ranking, Knowledge Graphs, and Large Language Models. They explore the potentials of bias in using LLMs for relevance judgments and the complexities of merging neural technologies with symbolic systems in search technology. The conversation delves into enhancing search algorithms, filtered vector search, entity linking with context-specific models, and the nuances of relevance judgments in research papers.
Enhancing neurosymbolic search by incorporating Entity Linking and Entity Re-Ranking for a deeper contextual understanding of text.
Challenges of utilizing large language models like GPT for relevance judgment, emphasizing model biases and interpretability concerns.
Exploring human-machine collaboration in information retrieval, blending human-defined facts with automated question-answering systems to enhance relevance evaluation.
Deep dives
Relevance and Connections in Information Retrieval
In the podcast episode, the discussion revolves around the intersection of neural technologies like deep learning with symbolic systems for information retrieval. Professor Deats highlights the importance of blending soft probabilistic notions with hard facts in neurosymbolic search. By defining entities like oysters in text beyond just words, a deeper understanding of their relevance and context can be achieved. The podcast explores the challenges and potential breakthroughs in entity linking, emphasizing the need for nuanced approaches to identifying entities in text.
Challenges of Using Large Language Models for Relevance Judgment
The episode raises critical questions about using large language models like GPT for relevance judgment. While these models may appear to align with human assessments, issues like model bias and interpretability pose significant challenges. The discussion delves into the limitations of solely relying on AI models for relevance judgments, citing concerns about model preferences and the potential loss of independence in evaluation. Additionally, the idea of leveraging large language models for query generation and hypothesis creation, rather than direct relevance judgment, emerges as a more constructive approach.
Innovative Approaches to Human-Machine Collaboration in Information Retrieval
An innovative perspective shared in the podcast explores the spectrum of human-machine collaboration in information retrieval. From leveraging human-driven relevance definitions with automated assistance to machine-generated hypotheses combined with human verification, the spectrum offers varied approaches to enhance the search process. Insights into utilizing human-defined facts and automated question-answering systems for evaluating relevance signal a shift towards more nuanced evaluation methodologies in information retrieval.
Exploring Novel Evaluation Paradigms in Information Retrieval
The podcast episode challenges traditional evaluation paradigms in information retrieval by proposing novel methods that blend human judgment with AI-powered systems. By considering human-curated fact extraction and utilizing them to assess system performance through question-answering capabilities, a fresh perspective is offered on evaluating relevance in search tasks. The episode emphasizes innovative evaluation strategies that incorporate human input to enhance the effectiveness and reliability of AI-driven information retrieval systems.
Innovative Method for Relevance Judgments
An innovative method for relevance judgments discussed in the podcast involves having humans generate their own tasks before assessing the relevance of information. By letting individuals create their own questions or tasks, it reduces bias and ensures a more objective evaluation process. The idea is to have humans come up with critical tasks, review search results, and potentially refine their questions. This method leverages automatic question-answering systems or machine learning to assist in the evaluation process, emphasizing the importance of considering human input in relevance assessments.
Exploring Alternative Approaches in Language Models
The podcast delves into the concept of exploring alternative approaches in language models beyond the current trend of massive parameter sizes. There is a discussion about whether medium-smart language models could be more efficient by integrating search engines effectively and interpreting user needs akin to how a human would process information. This alternative approach questions the necessity of extremely large models and suggests exploring architectures that focus on understanding user queries and search intents more naturally. The conversation highlights the need to consider different architectural designs to enhance the usefulness and efficiency of language models beyond traditional generative methods.
Hey everyone, thank you so much for watching the 49th episode of the Weaviate Podcast!! This podcast features Professor Laura Dietz from the University of New Hampshire! I came across Dr. Dietz's tutorial at ECIR on Neuro-Symbolic Approaches for Information Retrieval and am so grateful that she was interested in joining the Weaviate Podcast! I learned so much about Neurosymbolic Search, especially around the role of Entity Linking and Entity Re-Ranking -- as well as the topic of Knowledge Graphs and Vector Search. We also discussed Prof. Dietz and collaborators latest perspectives paper on Large Language Models for Relevance Judgment. TLDR this describes the idea of using LLMs to either generate synthetic queries for documents or say annotate the relevance for query, document pairs. We discussed this kind of idea with Leo Boytsov and his work on InPars, and have presented Promptagator on past episodes of the Weaviate Air show. Although this idea comes with a lot of potential, Dr. Dietz explains the potentials for bias and poor judgements, as well as generally diving more into the details of this kind of idea! I really hope you enjoy the podcast, we are more than happy to answer any questions you might have about these ideas, or discuss any of your ideas! Thanks so much for watching!
Check out Laura Dietz's Publications here: https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=IIXpJ8oAAAAJ&hl=en&oi=ao
ECIR 23 Tutorial: Neuro-Symbolic Approaches
for Information Retrieval: https://www.cs.unh.edu/~dietz/appendix/dietz2023neurosymbolic.pdf
Please check this paper out below, I think this is a severely underrated work in the Search / Information Retrieval community:
Perspectives on Large Language Models for Relevance Judgment: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.09161.pdf
Chapters
0:00 Introduction
0:15 Neurosymbolic Search
4:50 Entity Parsing and Vector Semantics
10:56 Query Intent Understanding
15:35 Knowledge Graphs and Vector Search
17:37 Symbolic Re-Ranking
22:10 ColBERT and Entity Ranking
26:25 Example - South America and Zika Virus IR
29:15 Knowledge Graph Query Languages with LLMs
35:10 We need more Knowledge Graphs!!
37:30 PrimeKG from Harvard BMI
39:40 Filtered Vector Search
42:20 LLM Entity Linking - “The” example
47:30 Cross Encoder Entity Focus?
48:25 Perspectives on LLMs for Relevance Judgments
55:28 Spectrum of Human-Machine Collaboration for Labeling
57:30 Use LLM to Create Relevance Labeling Interfaces
1:02:30 Importance for Weaviate
1:03:45 12 Authors’ 3 Conclusions
1:04:40 IR Research Community Challenge
1:06:55 Query Generation for Weaviate Users
1:13:05 Clustering Queries
1:17:30 Final Thoughts
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode