Parker's Pensées Ep. 213 - John Duns Scotus's Unique Thoughts on God and Man w/ Dr. Thomas Ward
Jan 5, 2023
Join Dr. Thomas Ward, a philosopher and historian specializing in John Duns Scotus, as he unpacks Scotus's unique philosophical arguments for God's existence and the nature of the Trinity, juxtaposed with Aquinas's views. The conversation touches on the principle of individuation, exploring 'thisness' and its relevance today, including links to modern concepts like NFTs. They also delve into the intriguing interplay of free will and divine influence, revealing Scotus's lasting impact on contemporary discussions of identity and theology.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
The Reviewer's Challenge
- Parker Settecase shares a story about a reviewer questioning the value of interpreting Duns Scotus.
- This inspired Settecase to address what Scotus thought and why it matters in his new book.
Univocity vs. Analogy
- The debate between Scotus and Aquinas centers on univocity vs. analogy in language about God.
- Scotus believes some terms have the same meaning for God and creatures, while Aquinas advocates for analogy due to God's unique nature.
God as Being
- Scotus's argument starts with "I am that I am," suggesting God is being itself.
- This raises questions about the distinction between God and creation if we participate in being.