The Herd with Colin Cowherd Colin Cowherd Podcast - BEST OF: Colin’s BEST TAKES from the Aaron Rodgers saga: Jets to Steelers
Aug 2, 2025
John Middlecoff, a former NFL scout renowned for his insights on player evaluations and team strategies, joins the discussion about Aaron Rodgers' tumultuous transition from the Jets to potentially joining the Steelers. They dive into the complexities of his character, team dynamics, and the repercussions of his decisions on draft strategies. The conversation also explores how Rodgers' past performances and personal life might influence his future, while comparing his situation to other star quarterbacks navigating their careers in a changing NFL landscape.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Aaron Rodgers: High Maintenance Reputation
- Aaron Rodgers has been considered high maintenance and moody by multiple sources throughout his career.
- This reputation contributed to him being unexpectedly released by both Green Bay and the Jets franchises.
Culture Trumping Talent in NFL Decisions
- The importance of team culture can outweigh talent when integrating veteran players.
- Aaron Glenn emphasized wanting a clean culture start, which excluded keeping Rodgers despite his skill.
Match Quarterbacks to Team Fit
- Teams should carefully assess veteran quarterbacks' fit before signing.
- Aaron Rodgers may best succeed where relationships and roster fit align, like with the Raiders or Colts.