Hosts discuss false accusations of racism against an author, cancelation scandals on YA Twitter, journey of a fan fiction writer who got signed by a major publisher, issue of review bombing on Goodreads, and the discussion on fake reviews and racial dynamics.
The podcast highlights the dangerous trend of accusing authors based on out-of-context quotes and explores the destructive impact it can have on reputations and book releases.
The podcast emphasizes the increasingly competitive nature of the YA market, with more authors vying for limited attention and resources.
Deep dives
The Controversy in YA Fiction
The podcast discusses a major controversy in the world of young adult fiction. The controversy revolves around Jessica Cluis, a YA author who was falsely accused of racism and violence. Other authors, consultants, and agents rushed to denounce her in an overwrought manner. The podcast highlights the dangerous trend of accusing authors based on out-of-context quotes and explores the destructive impact it can have on reputations and book releases.
The Decline of YA Fiction
The podcast examines the decline of the young adult fiction genre. Sales in the YA genre have been declining, and there are several theories as to why. Some suggest it's due to book bans or declining shelf space, while others believe it's because writers and publishers are targeting adult readers rather than young teens. The podcast emphasizes the increasingly competitive nature of the YA market, with more authors vying for limited attention and resources.
Goodreads and Review Bombing
The podcast delves into the issue of review bombing on Goodreads and its impact on authors. Goodreads, a popular book review platform, has experienced instances of review bombing, where users leave negative reviews without actually reading the book. This practice can be devastating for authors, especially smaller ones, as it affects their sales and reputation. The podcast discusses Goodreads' efforts to address this issue, including temporary limits on reviews during times of unusual activity.
This week on the premium edition of Blocked and Reported, Jesse and Katie discuss the latest YA blow-up, this one involving racism(?), review bombing, and an evil Star Wars stan who was just trying to be a good friend.