
Calvinism and Thomism: Friends or Foes?
Apr 4, 2022
Dr. Michael J. Lynch, an early modern soteriology scholar and Davenant Hall fellow, explores surprising overlap between Reformed and Thomistic thought. He highlights agreements on predestination, reprobation, and divine concurrence with human actions. Short, sharp explanations trace Vermigli, Davenant, Aquinas, and debates over infra- vs superlapsarianism.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Early Modern Catholics and Reformed Asked The Same Questions
- Early modern Roman Catholics and Reformed theologians asked the same questions about predestination, reprobation, and free choice rather than occupying wholly separate camps.
- Dr. Michael Lynch demonstrates overlap in doctrine and method by comparing Thomas Aquinas, Peter Martyr Vermigli, and others across 16th–18th century sources.
Vermigli Frames Predestination in Thomistic Categories
- Peter Martyr Vermigli’s scholastic treatment of predestination closely follows Thomas: predestination is providential and concerns supernatural ends like eternal life.
- Vermigli defines predestination to include both granting of grace (means) and the conferral of glory (end), echoing Thomistic categories.
Infralapsarianism Was Common Among Reformers
- Many early modern theologians, including Vermigli, held an infralapsarian order: predestination and reprobation presuppose the fall rather than causing it.
- This contrasts with some Dominicans and other scholastics who framed reprobation as antecedent to the fall (superlapsarianism).



