Experts debate whether Prime Minister Justin Trudeau should step down and the Liberals' growing fatigue. They discuss controversies, fiscal expenditure, childcare agreements, carbon pricing, reconciliation actions, and the discontent within the Liberal Party caucus. They emphasize preventing a conservative leader from taking over and the potential consequences for Canada.
One of the main challenges Justin Trudeau faces is the dwindling political capital he has, which hampers his ability to drive public opinion and instead often being driven by it.
Trudeau's leadership and his government have faced numerous challenges and criticisms, including perceived lack of economic policy and declining economic performance, criticism of foreign policy and national security efforts, and mixed perceptions of successes and shortcomings.
Deep dives
Public Opinion and Trudeau's Political Capital
One of the main challenges Justin Trudeau faces is the dwindling political capital he has, which hampers his ability to drive public opinion. Instead of shaping public opinion, he is often being driven by it. This lack of political capital is evident in negative views towards him, with many perceiving him as lacking vision, passion, and authenticity. As a result, there are growing calls for him to step down as Prime Minister. The Liberal Party members are concerned about the potential for a Conservative leader like Pierre Poilievre, who they believe could lead the country in a more conservative direction. There is a need for decisive action, either through a clear direction from Trudeau or by opening up the leadership to avoid a potential Polyev government.
Justin Trudeau's Legacy
As Justin Trudeau's time in office nears its end, reflection on his legacy is inevitable. His tenure has been marked by controversies, policy setbacks, and unfulfilled promises. While he made progress on some issues such as the expansion of Canada Pension Plan and the introduction of a national poverty strategy, others like greenhouse gas emissions and national unity remain contentious. Trudeau's commitment to feminism and gender equality has been notable, with initiatives like a gender-balanced cabinet and increased female representation in high-profile positions. Furthermore, his immigration policy and approach to reconciliation with Indigenous peoples have made an impact. However, the effectiveness and lasting impact of these policies in shaping the country's future remain to be seen.
Challenges and Criticisms
Trudeau's leadership and his government have faced numerous challenges and criticisms. One major criticism is the perceived lack of economic policy and support for businesses. Critics argue that there has been an indifference or even hostility towards businesses, leading to poor productivity statistics and declining economic performance. The government's foreign policy and national security efforts have also been widely criticized, with a lack of meaningful achievements in these areas. Additionally, the government has faced criticism for its handling of issues like climate change, defense, and international relations. Overall, the perception of Trudeau's leadership has been mixed, with both successes and shortcomings.
The Need for Change
Amidst declining support and concerns about Trudeau's leadership, there is a growing sentiment that a change is necessary. The Liberal Party is facing increasing challenges, with a shrinking electoral coalition. Young people, women, environmentalists, and some Muslim communities have expressed disappointment and disillusionment with the government's actions and policies. The need for a party reset is being highlighted, with some suggesting that Trudeau should step down to allow for a new leader who can bring fresh perspective and address the concerns of various demographics. At the same time, there is a recognition that replacing Trudeau presents its own risks and uncertainties, as there is no clear successor who stands out in terms of public appeal.
Eight years ago, Justin Trudeau and 30 ecstatic Liberal MPs walked up to Rideau Hall, ready to be sworn in as Canada’s next government. But after three elections, the Liberal glow has faded – drastically – as more and more Liberals suggest it’s time for the prime minister to step down.
This week on “It’s Political,” Abacus Data CEO David Coletto, P.E.I. Sen. Percy Downe and Toronto Star reporter Alex Ballingall join me to discuss whether Prime Minister Justin Trudeau should step down, and what the Liberals could do to address the public’s growing fatigue with their leader.
But first, if Trudeau were to step down, what would he be remembered for? We ask several close observers for their thoughts on the prime minister’s legacy. Some of their answers may surprise.
2:20 Mini documentary on Justin Trudeau’s legacy
31:55 Panel discussion on Justin Trudeau’s future as Liberal leader
Some of the clips this week were sourced from CBC, CPAC, Global, CTV, and The Guardian.
This episode of “It’s Political” was produced by Althia Raj and Michal Stein. Kevin Sexton mixed the program. Our theme music is by Isaac Joel.
In this episode: Abacus Data CEO David Coletto, Prince Edward Island Sen. Percy Downe, Toronto Star reporter Alex Ballingall, University of Calgary political science professor Lisa Young, UBC economics professor Kevin Milligan, Acadia University politics professor Alex Marland, Queen’s University adjunct professor Eugene Lang, the executive director of First Nations Child & Family Caring Society of Canada and McGill University School of Social Work professor Cindy Blackstock, Canadian Climate Institute executive vice-president Dale Beugin, and York University public administration professor Thomas Klassen. Hosted by Althia Raj.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode