Battling the official narrative – China's 'underground historians'
Nov 13, 2023
auto_awesome
Ian Johnson, a Pulitzer-Prize winning writer, discusses the underground historians in China who document suppressed aspects of history. They interview survivors from Communist labour camps and keep memoirs of the Cultural Revolution. The podcast explores the significance of history in the Chinese Communist Party's rule, the concept of heroism in Chinese culture, censorship paradox, and challenges faced by underground historians.
Controlling the narrative of history is a key strategy for the Chinese Communist Party to maintain its ruling power.
The underground historians in China play a crucial role in documenting alternative histories that challenge the official narrative, despite facing risks and suppression from the government.
Deep dives
The Importance of History in Chinese Politics
The Chinese Communist Party places significant importance on controlling the narrative of history to justify its ruling power. The party's official narrative presents itself as the savior of China, uniting and bringing prosperity to the country. However, the party sanitizes historical records, omitting past crises and failures, to maintain its legitimacy. Xi Jinping, learning from the USSR's fall, fears that alternative views of history could undermine the party's control, leading him to suppress and crush the underground historians documenting the hidden aspects of China's past.
The Work of Underground Historians in China
The underground historians in China are individuals who are actively involved in documenting and disseminating alternative histories that challenge the official narrative. Despite the risks they face, these historians continue to publish underground magazines, make documentary films, and write books. Their work covers various periods, from pre-1949 to the present, addressing topics such as power struggles during the Communist Party's early years, the Great Famine, the Cultural Revolution, and even the recent COVID-19 crisis. Their motivation stems partly from personal experiences and a belief in traditional Chinese values, such as justice and righteousness.
The Challenges and Impact of Underground Historians
The Chinese government focuses on suppressing impactful publications rather than individuals working in relative obscurity. While high-profile activists and journalists face harassment and censorship, the broader underground history movement involves tens of thousands of people across China. Access to knowledge and information has increased, thanks to the internet and the ability to bypass censorship with VPNs. Overseas Chinese communities also play a part in supporting and spreading the work of these historians. However, the introduction of the national security law in Hong Kong has posed new challenges, making it riskier for underground historians to publish and distribute their materials.
The Hope for Increased Global Recognition and Support
The underground historians' work deserves greater recognition and support from the international community. By translating their works, showcasing their films, and organizing retrospectives, the broader impact of their efforts can be amplified. Building an archive of their publications, films, and other works, such as the China Unofficial Archives website, allows for wider access to this valuable documentation. While the Chinese government attempts to rewrite history and promote its sanitized narrative, embracing the work of these underground historians helps to uphold the truth and expose the ongoing struggle against authoritarianism in China.
Controlling history is key to the Chinese Communist Party’s control of the country. Whether it’s playing up the ‘century of humiliation’, or whitewashing past mistakes like the Great Leap Forward or the Tiananmen Protests, the Party expends huge effort and resources on controlling the narrative.
That’s why it’s so important and interesting to look at those Chinese people who are documenting the bits of history that the Party doesn’t want you to know about. They interview survivors from Communist labour camps, or keep their own memoirs of the Cultural Revolution, and try to keep the memory of past horrors alive through film, magazines and paintings.
A new book called Sparks documents their work. Its author is Ian Johnson, a Pulitzer-Prize winning writer and long time China journalist. Ian calls these people the ‘underground historians’. He joins this episode of Chinese Whispers.