Copyediting Warning: Don't Rip Out The Soul of What You Create
Nov 22, 2023
auto_awesome
The podcast discusses preserving the soul of creative work, the importance of maintaining originality while incorporating feedback, refining and rewriting in their incubator, and reflecting on editing choices and retaining the essence of one's work.
11:52
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
Be cautious when incorporating feedback to avoid compromising the essence and originality of your work.
Constantly evaluate and refine your intellectual work to effectively convey the intended message.
Deep dives
Importance of Retaining the Soul of Your Work
In this podcast episode, the host shares a story from a book he's been reading called 'Tribe of Mentors' by Tim Ferriss. The story is about a filmmaker who, with the best intentions, revamped his film based on the feedback of a professor. Unfortunately, the changes made the film lose its soul and it was poorly received. The lesson here is that when receiving feedback or editing our work, we should be careful not to lose the essence and originality that makes it great. The host applies this lesson to his own project, an incubator for independent writers, where he has been rewriting and refining his presentation. He emphasizes the importance of making sure his voice and intentions are not compromised while still considering feedback.
Balancing Feedback and Staying True to Yourself
The host reflects on the delicate balance between incorporating feedback from editors and preserving one's voice and vision. He highlights the importance of being cautious when implementing edits, as compromising too much can attract the wrong audience or dilute the impact of the work. With his own project, the host strives to create a program that aligns with his values and that serves the writers he wants to attract. He shares his experience working with a copy editor who provides helpful feedback while allowing him to maintain the soul of his work.
Continual Refinement of Intellectual Work
The host reveals his personal experience with editing his project's video presentation. Despite going through numerous edits, he acknowledges the need for ongoing refinement. He specifically mentions wanting to add back a portion that he had previously removed, realizing that it adds a valuable element to his work. This illustrates the importance of constantly evaluating and refining intellectual work to ensure it effectively conveys the intended message. The host finishes by encouraging listeners to retain the unique essence and soul of their work, rather than simply making changes based on editor suggestions.