Charlotte Cushman, a groundbreaking 19th-century American actress, opens up about her journey from a heartbroken arrival in England to seeking the coveted role of Romeo. She shares the emotional turmoil of unreciprocated love and the challenges of blending her passion for acting with societal expectations. The conversation explores her rebellion against gender norms, the vibrant community of women artists in Rome, and her significant legacy as a pioneering performer who reshaped theatrical masculinity and love.
Charlotte Cushman's portrayal of traditionally male characters, like Romeo, redefined gender roles in theater by showcasing vulnerability and emotional depth.
Her journey reflects how personal relationships, particularly with Rosalie Sully, deeply influenced her emotional performances and artistic expression on stage.
Deep dives
Charlotte Cushman's Journey to Fame
Charlotte Cushman's journey as an actress began in the mid-19th century, marked by her passion for Shakespearean roles. Known for her strong voice and commanding presence, she faced the challenges of performing in an era that often dismissed women in theater. Moving from New York to London, she strived to earn recognition as she dealt with homesickness and the pressures of public scrutiny regarding her personal life. Her persistence paid off, as she not only secured key roles, including Lady Macbeth but also captivated audiences, setting a new standard for emotional depth in performances.
Love and Heartbreak
Cushman’s emotional turbulence was not limited to her professional life, as her personal relationships significantly influenced her journey. Her love for Rosalie Sully surfaced before her departure to England, resulting in intense feelings of longing and insecurity after they were separated. An entry from Charlotte's journal depicted her fears of losing Rosalie to another while she was away, reflecting the depth of her feelings. These heartaches played a pivotal role in how she expressed vulnerability on stage, further blurring the lines between her personal and professional identities.
Defying Gender Norms in Performance
An integral part of Cushman’s legacy was her role in breaking gender norms within theater by embodying traditionally male characters. She made headlines when she played Romeo opposite her sister Susan as Juliet, radically interpreting the character to evoke a more sensitive version of masculinity, which connected deeply with audiences. Critics praised her for redefining Romeo as a character who could express vulnerability and emotions openly, shifting the public perception of gender roles in performance. This pioneering portrayal not only garnered accolades but also challenged the status quo, paving the way for future theatrical interpretations.
Creating a Community of Women Artists
Cushman's life in Rome illustrated her commitment to fostering a supportive environment for women artists. Along with her partner Matilda Hayes and fellow artists, they formed a vibrant collective known as the Jolly Bachelors, where they shared their work and supported each other's ambitions. This gathering of creative minds provided a safe haven for exploring their identities in a more liberated environment compared to conservative America. Through this community, Cushman helped establish a space where women could thrive in their artistic pursuits, leaving a lasting impact on women in the arts.
When Charlotte Cushman arrived in England, she was heartbroken. But she began looking for work as an actor. There was one part she really wanted: Romeo.
Want to listen to This is Love ad-free? Sign up for Criminal Plus – you’ll get This is Love, Criminal, and Phoebe Reads a Mystery ad-free. Plus, behind-the-scenes bonus episodes of Criminal and other exclusive benefits. Learn more and sign up here.