Why Robert Hur Described Joe Biden as an “Elderly Man with a Poor Memory”
Mar 22, 2024
auto_awesome
Discussion on special prosecutor Robert Hur's report calling Biden 'an elderly man with a poor memory' and the controversy it sparked. Analysis of Biden vs. Trump handling of classified documents. Examination of evidence against Biden and the legal implications. Insights into writing legal reports for different audiences. Debate on delays in Trump's federal trials and implications for re-election.
Robert Hur's report on Biden highlighted his age and memory, leading to controversy.
Contrast in approach: Biden cooperated in document investigation, in contrast to Trump's resistance.
Deep dives
Biden Cleared of Criminal Charges in Herr's Report
Special Counsel Robert Herr's long-awaited report concluded that no criminal charges against President Biden were warranted in the mishandling of classified documents case. While the report vindicated Biden, it also referred to him as an elderly man with a poor memory, sparking criticism from Biden and his supporters for being inflammatory and prejudicial.
Contrast Between Trump and Biden's Handling of Classified Documents
The investigation into Donald Trump's retention of classified documents highlighted his resistance in returning them to the government, leading to a felony indictment. In contrast, Biden readily returned the documents found at his home and cooperated fully with investigators, showcasing a distinct difference in approach and behavior.
Role of Special Counsel in Trump and Biden Cases
Special counsels play a crucial role in high-profile investigations involving top government officials like the president. Their independence from the regular justice system allows them to conduct thorough investigations and make recommendations based on the evidence gathered, addressing conflicts of interest within the Justice Department.
Trump's Trial Delays and Immunity Arguments
Former President Trump's facing multiple felony counts, causing trial delays and legal maneuvers. Delays in federal criminal trials, including those related to classified documents and election interference, raise questions about the legal system's pace. Trump's immunity arguments present a complex issue involving potential future Supreme Court decisions and implications for presidential prosecution.
The New Yorker contributor Jeannie Suk Gersen joins Tyler Foggatt to discuss her interview with Robert Hur, the special prosecutor who caused a political uproar with his report on his investigation into President Biden’s handling of classified documents. The report, which referred to Biden as “a sympathetic, well-meaning, elderly man with a poor memory,” elicited a furious response from the White House—but, Gersen argues, its meaning and Hur’s motivations may have been misunderstood. Gersen and Foggatt also discuss the likelihood that the federal cases against Trump will go to trial before Election Day, and what Americans might expect if they do not.
Read Jeannie Suk Gersen’s piece on Robert Hur here.
To discover more podcasts from The New Yorker, visit newyorker.com/podcasts. To send feedback on this episode, write to themail@newyorker.com.