Asad Dandia, a young Muslim man under NYPD surveillance, shares his poignant story of distrust and betrayal within his community. Historian Matt Guariglia unpacks the historical relationship between policing and immigration, revealing how colonial practices influence modern methods. Investigative journalist Albert Samaha adds context about the oppressive legacy of law enforcement, highlighting the fight against invasive surveillance in marginalized communities. Together, they challenge the complexities of identity, surveillance, and systemic reform in New York City.
The podcast highlights how historically, the NYPD's surveillance and informant tactics have eroded trust within immigrant communities, perpetuating systemic oppression.
Asad Dandia's personal experience of betrayal and subsequent activism against police surveillance underscores the struggle for accountability and representation in marginalized communities.
Deep dives
Surveillance and Betrayal
Asad Dandia experiences a shocking revelation when an off-duty cop and friend informs him that he is under police surveillance. Concerned for his safety, the friend reveals that the police possess a file with Asad's name and photos, which sends Asad into a state of fear and anxiety about his future and relationships. Despite feeling terrified and unsure whom to confide in, Asad tries to dismiss the situation as a misunderstanding, hoping to live his life without repercussions. This pivotal moment sets the stage for the unfolding narrative of trust, fear, and community dynamics.
Community and Friendship
Asad’s connection with his community is evident through his involvement in a mutual aid organization, Muslims Giving Back, which aims to support those in need within their neighborhood. His friendship with Shamir Rahman, a young man who seeks guidance in understanding Muslim rituals and who quickly becomes involved in community activities, symbolizes the bonds formed through shared faith and ideals. The development of their friendship, marked by shared meals and nighttime prayers, creates a sense of trust and intimacy that eventually leads to deep feelings of betrayal. When Shamir's true identity as a police informant is revealed, this sense of community is shattered, highlighting the vulnerabilities of trust within immigrant communities.
Historical Context of Policing
The podcast delves into the historical context of policing in New York City, especially regarding immigrants, interpreting the surveillance tactics employed by the NYPD as part of a broader pattern throughout history. Authorities often view immigrant communities with suspicion, leading the police to create informants as a means to control and surveil those deemed as potential threats. This historical narrative connects past and present practices, showcasing a longstanding tendency of law enforcement to target marginalized groups under the guise of national security. By examining these relationships, the discussions raise critical questions about civic trust and the role of policing in diverse urban landscapes.
The Aftermath and Resistance
Following the unsettling revelations about Shamir, Asad Dandia becomes an outspoken advocate against police surveillance in Muslim communities. His activism culminates in a lawsuit against the NYPD for unconstitutional surveillance, symbolizing a broader resistance against systemic oppression. Asad reflects on the difficulties of claiming New York as home, given the police's historical betrayal of communities like his own. Through collective actions and legal victories, the narrative emphasizes the ongoing struggle for representation and accountability in policing, highlighting the enduring impact of historical practices on contemporary society.
New York’s police start to realize that beating up and arresting immigrants is making them distrustful of cops. In response, a police chief has an idea, borne out of his time colonizing the Philippines: control the population by recruiting local community members to police their own people.
From Wondery, Crooked Media and PushBlack.
Empire City is made with a commitment to ensure the stories of those who were and are still impacted by the NYPD are always part of the stories we tell ourselves about the police, about America, and about democracy.
Follow Empire City: The Untold Origin Story of the NYPD on the Wondery App or wherever you listen to your podcasts. You can binge all episodes early and ad-free on Wondery+. Join Wondery+ in the Wondery App, Apple Podcasts or Spotify. Start your free trial by visiting wondery.com/links/empire-city/ now.