My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark MFM Minisode 451
Sep 1, 2025
In a heartwarming tribute to Grandparents' Day, the hosts share captivating family murder stories, including a great-grandfather's mysterious death in post-WWI Italy. They delve into humorous anecdotes about a legendary donkey and a grandfather's survival tale, highlighting family resilience. The vibrant life of a Danish grandmother brings laughs as unexpected secrets are unveiled. Heartfelt stories from a grandmother's funeral blend humor with poignant moments, while a heroic dog named Smokey saves the day, reminding us of the legacies our grandparents leave behind.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Mysterious Ischia Shooting
- Karen Kilgariff recounts her great-grandfather's suspicious death in post-WWI Ischia involving a shot allegedly from a kicked rifle or a jealous captain.
- The story contrasts a folk explanation (a donkey accident) with a more plausible affair-driven motive.
Rebar Accident Survivor
- A listener describes their grandpa's Phineas Gage-like accident where rebar pierced from the back of his head to under his eye but he remained conscious.
- Firefighters practiced cutting rebar and used a saw from the truck to free him, and he fully recovered to play pickleball for years.
Feisty Danish Grandma
- A listener shares stories of their Danish grandmother Inger who favored cigarettes over swinger parties when forced to choose for her heart.
- Inger was opinionated, fought with TSA, and remained unapologetically herself into old age.