Angela Saini - Patriarchy and the Roots of Gendered Oppression
Oct 4, 2023
auto_awesome
Angela Saini, author of 'The Patriarchs: How Men Came to Rule', discusses the origins and embedded nature of patriarchy in societies. Topics include exploring gender diversity in different societies, the impact of colonization on matrilineal societies, advancements in archaeological and genetic evidence, and the assumptions and connections of patriarchy worldwide.
Patriarchy is not a single overarching system, but rather multiple patriarchies that vary across different parts of the world.
Ancient societies like ancient Greece and Rome were selectively used to justify and reinforce patriarchal power structures throughout history.
The consolidation of patriarchal power was significantly influenced by the emergence of the first states, particularly in ancient Mesopotamia.
Deep dives
The Complexity of Defining Patriarchy
Patriarchy is a complex concept that is difficult to define. In her book, Angela Sainey argues that there is not a single overarching patriarchy that controls every aspect of life, but rather multiple patriarchy's that vary across different parts of the world. These patriarchy's are constantly evolving and changing, serving the interests of the social elites at the top. Sainey emphasizes that patriarchy is a form of elite male domination, rather than the domination of all women by all men.
The Influence of Ancient Societies
Sainey explores the influence of ancient societies like ancient Greece and Rome on the development of patriarchal norms. She challenges the idea that these societies are often held up as models of civilization and democracy, pointing out their inherent misogyny, hierarchy, and slavery. She argues that these societies were selectively used to justify and reinforce patriarchal power structures throughout history, rather than being representative of natural or universal gender relations.
The Role of States in Patriarchy
The emergence of the first states, particularly in ancient Mesopotamia, is identified as a significant turning point in the consolidation of patriarchal power. Sainey suggests that states became concerned with population growth and defense, leading to increased control over familial and gender dynamics. The demands of the state placed pressure on women to bear more children and on men to fulfill military duties, solidifying patriarchal norms and gender roles.
Resistance and Assimilation
Sainey acknowledges that while some individuals, both men and women, benefit from aligning themselves with patriarchal power structures, there have always been those who resist and challenge these norms. She highlights examples of women's resistance movements, as well as men who reject traditional notions of masculinity. The existence of both assimilation and resistance demonstrates the complex and nuanced nature of patriarchal systems and the ongoing struggle for gender equality.
The Potential for Change
Despite centuries of patriarchal power, Sainey remains optimistic about the potential for change. She believes that societies can be remade along more equal lines, and points to examples of historical and contemporary movements that have challenged patriarchal systems. Sainey emphasizes the importance of understanding the dynamics of power and actively resisting patriarchal norms, rather than accepting them as natural or inevitable.
What is 'patriarchy' and where do its origins lie? How did it become embedded in societies from prehistory to the present? What part do we all play in maintaining patriarchal structures, and can they be dismantled? These are some of the pressing questions we discuss in this episode with Angela Saini, author of a fascinating new book 'The Patriarchs: How Men Came to Rule' (Harper Collins): https://harpercollins.co.uk/products/the-patriarchs-how-men-came-to-rule-angela-saini?variant=39997855268942
Angela is an award-winning British journalist, currently based in New York. She teaches science writing at Massachusetts Institute of Technology, presents radio and television programmes, and has written for National Geographic, the Financial Times, and Wired. In 2022 she was a Logan Nonfiction Program fellow, and a fellow of the Humboldt Residency Programme in Berlin. 'The Patriarchs' follows on from her earlier books, the critically acclaimed 'Superior: The Return of Race Science' and 'Inferior: How Science Got Women Wrong'.