The Theological Roots of Capitalism: A Conversation with Economist Benjamin M. Friedman
Mar 24, 2021
auto_awesome
Benjamin M. Friedman, a Harvard economist and author of "Religion and the Rise of Capitalism," dives into the profound connections between theology and economics. He discusses how religious ideas influenced key economic theorists like Adam Smith, and the evolution of economic thought from Calvinism to human agency. The fascinating role of the 'invisible hand' reveals divine implications in free-market principles. Friedman further explores how differing eschatological views shape contemporary economic policies, demonstrating the continuing relevance of theology in today's capitalism.
The evolution of modern economics is deeply rooted in religious thinking, as foundational theorists like Adam Smith were influenced by their theological contexts.
The significant presence of Protestant clergymen among the American Economic Association's founders illustrates the historical intertwining of faith and economic thought.
Competing narratives of the Gospel of Wealth and the Social Gospel in the 19th century demonstrate the profound impact of economic ideologies on religious expectations and social justice initiatives.
Deep dives
The Intersection of Religion and Economics
The podcast discusses the pivotal relationship between religious thinking and the development of modern Western economics, emphasizing that religion significantly influenced economic philosophy. Professor Benjamin M. Friedman argues that foundational economic theorists like Adam Smith and David Hume were shaped by the highly theological context of their time, which contrasts with the common narrative that associates modern economics solely with secular Enlightenment ideas. Friedman contends that the religious debates and ideas prevalent in the English-speaking Protestant world during the 18th century were essential stimuli for their economic theories. This perspective reframes the historical understanding of economics, suggesting that the roots of economic thought were not exclusively secular but deeply intertwined with religious beliefs.
Founding Members of the American Economic Association
A surprising statistic is highlighted regarding the founding members of the American Economic Association (AEA) in 1885, where 23 out of 181 members were Protestant clergymen. This strong connection suggests that early economists were significantly influenced by religious perspectives and the social gospel movement. Some founding members, like Richard Ely, explicitly connected their economic writings to Christianity, indicating a historical blending of faith and economics. This contrasts sharply with contemporary views of economics as a purely secular discipline and invites a reconsideration of how religious foundations have historically shaped economic thought.
Worldview and Economic Theories
The podcast explores the concept of worldview, asserting that the foundational beliefs individuals hold largely shape their understanding of economic principles. Friedman references thinkers like Einstein and Erik Erikson to explain that, for early economists like Smith and Hume, the prevailing religious worldview provided the intellectual framework from which their economic theories emerged. This perspective challenges the notion that economic thought can be developed in a vacuum and emphasizes the significance of pre-existing beliefs. By asserting that one cannot approach economic reasoning without the influence of a worldview, the discussion underscores the enduring impact of religious thought on modern economic practice.
Two Rival Gospels: Wealth and Social Responsibility
The podcast addresses the emergence of two competing narratives in the late 19th century: the Gospel of Wealth, advocating for economic prosperity, and the Social Gospel, emphasizing social justice and caring for the poor. Leaders like Henry Ward Beecher and Russell Conwell promoted the idea that economic growth would inevitably lead to moral and social progress, reflecting a belief akin to David Hume's thoughts on economics. In contrast, figures from the Social Gospel movement advocated for active intervention to address poverty and inequality, viewing the church as a leader in societal change. These dual narratives showcase how economic expansion transformed religious and social expectations during a time of rapid industrialization.
The Influence of Theology on Economic Policy
The podcast concludes with a consideration of how contemporary economic policy choices are influenced by religious affiliation. Friedman notes that while the intellectual discipline of economics has become less susceptible to external influences, the beliefs held by the public still significantly affect policy decisions. Insights into how individuals' religious backgrounds inform their economic perspectives suggest ongoing interdependencies between faith and economics. This reflection on the past and present highlights the necessity of understanding how religious contexts shape not only individual worldviews but also broader economic policies in society.
This is Thinking in Public, a program dedicated to intelligent conversation about frontline theological and cultural issues with the people who are shaping them.
Sign up to receive every new Thinking in Public release in your inbox.