Richard J. Evans, "Hitler's People: The Faces of the Third Reich" (Penguin, 2024)
Dec 8, 2024
auto_awesome
Richard Evans, a revered authority on Nazi Germany and author of The Third Reich Trilogy, delves into the intricacies of Hitler's inner circle. He examines the personal and professional lives of key figures like Goebbels and Himmler, revealing their complex roles in facilitating the Holocaust. Evans challenges the notion of perpetrators as mere monsters, emphasizing the ordinary origins of these individuals. He also discusses the implications of contemporary free speech debates and the responsibility of historians to balance evidence with personal beliefs.
Richard Evans illustrates the normalcy and social integration of Nazi leaders, revealing their shared cultural traits with mainstream German society.
The podcast draws parallels between historical Nazi propaganda tactics and contemporary populist movements, highlighting the dangers of complacency towards extremist ideologies.
Deep dives
The Origins of Interest in German History
The speaker describes how a childhood fascination with post-war London, particularly the bomb sites and remnants of World War II, sparked an interest in German history. Growing up in an environment filled with discussions about wartime experiences and the impact of the war on society, curiosity was piqued by the question of why such devastation occurred. The speaker's academic journey led him to Oxford, where a resurgence of interest in German history was evident. This period saw a generation of historians begin to explore the Nazis and the conditions that led to their rise, motivating the speaker to dive deeper into this subject.
Writing 'People, The Faces of the Third Reich'
The speaker discusses the inspiration behind the structure and content of the book, which profiles significant individuals from the Nazi regime. By dividing the book into sections that cover figures from Hitler himself to more obscure, lower-ranking Nazis, it creates a comprehensive view of the regime's hierarchy. Acknowledging the need for reliable historical accounts, the speaker chooses representative individuals from various backgrounds, despite the complexity of capturing the essence of every key figure. This organized approach allows for an exploration of their motivations and the contexts in which they operated, contributing to a larger understanding of Nazi Germany.
Shared Ideological and Cultural Connections
The book's examination of commonalities among Nazi leaders reveals their early acceptance of Hitler's leadership and the rampant anti-Semitism that characterized the regime. The speaker argues that these individuals were not fringe characters but represented mainstream German society, often coming from the middle class with shared cultural traits. This insight challenges the notion that they were simply deranged criminals, instead highlighting their normalcy and integration into German life. Significant point is made regarding the psychological dimensions, as many of these men displayed characteristics common in broader segments of society, complicating the narrative of straightforward evil.
Lessons for Contemporary Society
Reflecting on modern-day political movements, the speaker draws parallels between the rise of populist strongmen today and the historical context of Nazi Germany. Observations are made about how populists exploit societal discontent, particularly regarding immigration, without invoking militaristic ambitions typical of past dictators. The speaker emphasizes the importance of resisting anti-democratic forces and the tendency to compromise with extremist elements, which ultimately undermines democracy. This deep concern for the current state of political affairs serves as a warning against complacency and a call to strive for truth and integrity in political discourse.
Richard Evans, author of the acclaimed The Third Reich Trilogy and over two dozen other volumes on modern Europe, is our preeminent scholar of Nazi Germany. Having spent half a century searching for the truths behind one of the most horrifying episodes in human history, in Hitler's People: The Faces of the Third Reich(Penguin Press, 2024), he brings us back to the original site of the Nazi movement: namely, the lives of its most important members.
Working in concentric circles out from Hitler and his closest allies, Evans forms a typological framework of Germany society under Nazi rule from the top down. With a novelist's eye for detail, Evans explains the Third Reich through the personal failings and professional ambitions of its members, from its most notorious deputies--like Goebbels, the regime's propagandist, and Himmler, the Holocaust's chief architect--to the crucial enforcers and instruments of the Nazi agenda that history has largely forgotten--like the schoolteacher Julius Streicher and the actress Leni Riefenstahl. Drawing on a wealth of recently unearthed historical sources, Hitler's People lays bare the inner and outer lives of the characters whose choices led to the deaths of millions.
Nearly a century after Hitler's rise, the leading nations of the West are once again being torn apart by a will to power. By telling the stories of these infamous lives as human lives, Evans asks us to grapple with the complicated nature of complicity, showing us that the distinctions between individual and collective responsibility--and even between pathological evil and rational choice--are never easily drawn.