In this conversation, Israeli intelligence expert Uri Bar-Joseph analyzes the shocking failures of Israel's intelligence leading up to the October 7 Hamas attack. He emphasizes how a historical focus on military strength overshadowed necessary diplomatic efforts. Bar-Joseph draws parallels to past intelligence oversights and stresses the need for real-time data collection and cultural understanding regarding Hamas. Additionally, he discusses the importance of intellectual humility in analysis, urging a shift toward a more balanced and inclusive approach to national security.
The October 7 Hamas attack exemplified a 'perfect failure' in Israeli intelligence, revealing a critical misjudgment in threat assessment and analysis.
Uri Bar-Joseph argues for a paradigm shift in Israel's intelligence strategy, emphasizing the need for balancing military strength with diplomatic engagement.
Deep dives
Lessons from Historical Intelligence Failures
The podcast discusses the concept of intelligence failures by comparing historical events like the 1973 Arab-Israeli War with more recent occurrences. In 1973, Israel's intelligence had a successful collection of information but failed in analysis, leading to a surprise attack. This pattern is seen in the recent October 7 attack, where Israel reportedly had minimal actionable intelligence despite having access to some of the best collection systems worldwide. The analysis emphasizes that intelligence agencies often do not learn from past failures and therefore risk repeating them.
Understanding Misjudgments about Threats
The analysis of the October 7 attack highlights significant misjudgments in assessing Hamas's intentions, as intelligence analysts believed Hamas was deterred while evidence suggested otherwise. Analysts ignored clear indicators, such as Hamas's military preparations that indicated an imminent threat, illustrating a gap between observation and interpretation. The stress on the need for analysts to have humility and be aware of what they do not know is underscored, as relying solely on assumptions can lead to critical errors. The podcast emphasizes that it is essential for intelligence analysts to actively listen to adversaries and understand their culture to effectively interpret their actions.
The Need for a Comprehensive Intelligence Strategy
An urgent call for a broad examination of Israel's intelligence strategy and operations is advocated, highlighting that military intelligence has shifted its focus away from providing strategic warnings. There is a suggestion that a disproportionate emphasis on collecting targets for military action has compromised the fundamental role of intelligence in national security. This has resulted in a failure to adapt to changing threats, culminating in the October 7 attack and previous conflicts. The overall message stresses the need for a balanced approach, integrating military might with diplomatic efforts to address security issues effectively.
Michael talks with Israeli intelligence expert Uri Bar-Joseph, who dissects the stunning failure of Israeli intelligence ahead of the October 7th Hamas attack—a “perfect failure” that shook the foundations of Israel’s vaunted security apparatus. Tracing the roots of this debacle back decades, Bar-Joseph discusses the fatal flaw in Israel’s national security strategy: prioritizing military might over diplomatic engagement. It’s part of Uri’s new book in Hebrew, 'Beyond the Iron Wall.'
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode