In this discussion, President Zelensky makes a compelling case for utilizing British-made 'Storm Shadow' missiles to bolster Ukraine's defense against Russia. He shares his visionary 'plan for victory,' while UK Labour leader Keir Starmer passionately supports this strategy. On the other hand, President Biden voices concerns about escalated military conflict. The conversation navigates the delicate balance between military aid and the pursuit of peace, raising questions about the future of Ukraine's sovereignty amid ongoing geopolitical tensions.
Ukraine views the Storm Shadow missiles as essential for penetrating Russian defenses, but Biden's caution highlights concerns about escalating global conflict.
The complexity of peace talks is exacerbated by deep-seated grievances and ongoing violence, making compromise between Ukraine and Russia unlikely.
Deep dives
The Debate Over Storm Shadow Missiles
The discussion centers around the potential use of Storm Shadow missiles, a weapon system desired by Ukraine to strike deeper into Russian territory. These missiles, capable of bypassing some Russian defenses due to their speed and design, are seen as crucial for Ukraine's strategy against Russia's military capabilities. However, President Biden's hesitation reflects concerns about escalating the conflict further, as using Western-supplied weapons could be perceived as direct NATO involvement in the war. This dilemma raises questions about the balance between supporting Ukraine and avoiding a broader confrontation with Russia.
Challenges to Peace Negotiations
The complexities surrounding peace talks are highlighted by the entrenched positions of both Ukraine and Russia. President Zelensky's proposed victory plan aims to establish buffer zones, but historical grievances and ongoing violence complicate any attempt to negotiate. The harsh realities of casualties and infrastructure damage have created a profound sense of bitterness on both sides, making any kind of compromise appear unlikely. Observers note that the conditions may necessitate a ceasefire or diplomatic efforts driven by mutual exhaustion rather than a clear victor.
The Role of International Politics
International dynamics play a critical role in the ongoing conflict, particularly regarding US leadership and the potential outcomes of the upcoming elections. The contrasting foreign policy approaches of current and future US administrations could significantly impact the conflict; a shift in power could either escalate tensions or provide opportunities for negotiation. The possibility of different responses from NATO allies based on the US electoral outcomes adds another layer of complexity to the conflict. As such, the interconnectedness of international relations continues to shape the trajectory of the war and prospective peace efforts.
At the UN General Assembly next week, Ukraine's President Zelensky will present his 'plan for victory' to world leaders. Key to that victory, he thinks, is being allowed to shoot British-made 'Storm Shadow' missiles into Russian territory. Keir Starmer agrees, Joe Biden does not. Is Biden right to be worried - or is this all part of a wider plan by the president to bring us closer to some kind of peace?
This podcast was brought to you thanks to the support of readers of The Times and The Sunday Times. Subscribe today: http://thetimes.com/thestory
Guest: Mark Urban, writer and columnist, The Sunday Times.