The Reformanda Initiative 85. Is Rome a True Church? Wrestling with History, Reformers, and Rome Today
Apr 28, 2025
Matthew Johnston, a pastor and Fellow at the Reformanda Initiative in Italy, dives deep into the contentious question of whether Rome can be deemed a true church. He unpacks the Reformed criteria for a true church, highlighting the tension between Roman doctrine and Scripture. While acknowledging the presence of Christian elements in Rome, he asserts they fall short of true church status. They also discuss the implications of calling Rome a true church and reflect on historical developments like Vatican I and II, shaping the contemporary debate.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Marks Define A True Church
- The Reformers defined a true church by marks: pure preaching, sacraments rightly administered, and ecclesiastical discipline.
- These marks determine church legitimacy more than mere presence of Scripture or rituals.
Doctrine Against Scripture Disqualifies
- If a church's core doctrines oppose Scripture, that alone disqualifies it as a true church.
- Turretin argues Rome's opposing doctrine suffices to deny it the status of a true church.
Shared Elements Aren't Proof
- Rome contains genuine Christian elements like creeds, baptismal formula, and Scripture reading, but those do not equal a true church.
- Reformers treated these overlaps as vestiges, not proof of ecclesial legitimacy.
