#36 Microbiome: Fountain of Health? Or We Just Don't Know

Send us a text

Please answer a few questions to help my podcast

The microbiome receives lots of attention, but what do we really know? In this episode, Dr. Bobby unpacks whether your gut bacteria are truly the key to preventing disease—or if the science still needs to catch up.

Microbiome buzz is everywhere—from promises of inflammation relief and weight loss to claims about mental health and longevity. But what does the research actually say? Dr. Bobby begins with four essential questions: Is the microbiome important? Does it change based on our habits? Do those changes cause disease? And can restoring it improve our health?

Using his open-minded skeptic lens, Dr. Bobby explains that while mouse studies offer compelling clues—like the famous “fat mouse, skinny poop” experiments showing weight gain linked to microbiome transplants—the same effects haven’t translated reliably in humans. A rare exception is C. difficile colitis. Here, fecal transplants have up to a 90% success rate, with medical societies endorsing this approach (source).

For other conditions like diabetes, rheumatoid arthritis, and Crohn’s disease, microbiome disruptions are well-documented. Still, whether these disruptions cause the illness—or are just innocent bystanders—is unclear. In diabetes, for instance, small studies and reviews show possible improvement in insulin sensitivity after fecal transplants (source) and mixed outcomes with probiotics (source), but nothing rivals the proven power of standard therapies like metformin.

Dr. Bobby also explores whether lifestyle choices—such as eating more fermented foods, fiber, and taking probiotics—can truly “reset” your microbiome and keep us healthy. The answer? These may enhance diversity and gut health, but current data doesn’t yet confirm long-term disease prevention. He references findings from the NIH Human Microbiome Project (source) and other studies showing how gut bacteria influence immune development, vitamin production, and digestion (source).

He also touches on terminology: probiotics are live bacteria (think yogurt and kombucha), prebiotics are their food (found in beans and whole grains), and postbiotics are beneficial byproducts. Each plays a role, but their direct impact on human disease remains uncertain.

Dr. Bobby closes with this: he enjoys homemade yogurt and sauerkraut, but doesn’t chase expensive probiotic supplements. “It can’t hurt and might help,” he says—but don’t expect probiotics to fully replace conventional treatment. As research evolves, he’ll continue to watch the space closely—and encourages listeners to let him know if this type of deep-dive, still-unsettled topic resonates.

Takeaways:

1. Fecal transplants are a proven, effective microbiome treatment—for C. difficile, not for general wellness.
2. Most microbiome buzz comes from animal studies, and evidence in humans is still preliminary and inconsistent.
3. Eating more fiber and fermented foods likely supports gut health, but won’t replace proven medical treatments.

Complete Dr. Bobby’s feedback survey here to help shape future episodes.