271 Wikipedians Are at War Over the Inclusion of Roads and Highways

What makes something notable? What kind of sources are needed for a thing to have a Wikipedia article about it? These philosophical issues are discussed by volunteer Wikipedia editors constantly to ensure that the non-profit encyclopedia is accurate and relevant.

But a community of self-described "Road Geeks" has been at odds with Wikipedia's standards for some time. They're on a mission to catalog every road in North America, but other Wiki editors claim that this content is too granular, or has no secondary (journalistic) sources. But why would these sources exist when roads just...exist? And when should primary research — looking at a map, or even out your own window! — be considered for inclusion in the world's largest knowledge base?

Tired of having their road articles deleted or modified, the Road Geeks have now "seceded" from Wikipedia to create their own Wiki on a sympathetic site called AARoads. While this may seem like a bunch of semantic nerds fighting on the Internet, it actually has fascinating implications for who gets to decide what is important, and what Wikipedia is supposed to be.

Alli and Lindsey talk with Ben, a longtime Wikipedia editor and road enthusiast who is part of the movement to carve out a home for the historical and cultural value of road knowledge online. You can find the new wiki here: https://wiki.aaroads.com/

Take our quick, anonymous survey to help us make the show the best it can be! https://form.jotform.com/232267699994075

Support 2G1P on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/2G1P

Join the 2G1P Discord community: http://discord.gg/2g1p

Join the 2G1P Facebook Group: https://www.facebook.com/groups/2girls1podcast/

Email us: 2G1Podcast@gmail.com

Call the show and leave a message! (347) 871-6548  

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices