Anna and Phoebe's soup protest at the National Gallery starkly highlights the urgent conflict between climate action and societal values surrounding art.
The severe sentences for climate activists underscore the increasing risks and harsh legal repercussions linked to direct action in today’s political climate.
Deep dives
The Act of Defiance
The episode highlights the shocking act of defiance by activists Anna Holland and Phoebe Plummer, who threw Heinz tomato soup on a Vincent van Gogh painting at the National Gallery. This action was a calculated move aimed at drawing attention to the climate crisis, as they sought to contrast the value of art with the urgent need for action on environmental issues. Their choice of soup was strategic for its vibrant color, ensuring it would create a striking visual impact and generate media coverage. The carefully planned stunt culminated in Anna and Phoebe gluing themselves to the gallery wall while delivering a speech that questioned societal priorities regarding art versus life.
Consequences of Activism
Following their protest, Anna and Phoebe received significant sentences, two years and 20 months respectively, for damaging artwork. This unexpected outcome shocked the activists and the broader climate movement, raising questions about the risks involved in direct action. Their sentences exemplified a growing trend of severe penalties imposed on climate activists in the UK, highlighting a complex relationship between civil disobedience and legal repercussions. The podcast explores the emotional and relational toll on individuals who choose activism, including feelings of guilt for prioritizing their cause over personal relationships.
The Rise of Just Stop Oil
The episode discusses the emergence of Just Stop Oil as a response to previous climate activism strategies that activists felt were ineffective. Founded in 2022, Just Stop Oil aimed to escalate the disruption caused by climate protests, pushing against government inaction despite years of peaceful efforts from groups like Greenpeace and Extinction Rebellion. Historical context is provided, noting past successful disruptive actions and how the political landscape has shifted to create a more hostile environment for activists. The group's tactics increasingly involve high-stakes actions, knowing that the risk of prison time is a possibility that many members have come to accept.
Personal Transformations
The experiences of Anna and fellow activist George Simonson illustrate personal transformations that fuel their commitment to climate activism. Both individuals describe pivotal moments that changed their perspectives, shifting from apathy to urgency in addressing climate issues. Anna's journey began with her admiration for those who made sacrifices for their causes, while George's awakening stemmed from a realization of the inadequacy of mere personal efforts to combat climate change. Their involvement with Just Stop Oil not only provided a sense of purpose but also fostered a community of like-minded individuals, reinforcing their resolve to enact meaningful change despite the personal sacrifices that accompany their actions.
In episode one of Committed, Clare Hymer and Rivkah Brown meet the imprisoned Just Stop Oil activists who took direct action against the climate crisis and faced dire consequences. By blocking roads, climbing bridges and throwing soup at paintings, they made headlines – and became national hate figures in the process. We find out how […]
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
