Haaretz Podcast ‘I couldn't vote for Trump, but I'm glad he won’: Top Jewish podcaster Jonah Platt on Israel, Gaza and antisemitism in America
13 snips
Nov 10, 2025 Jonah Platt, an actor-turned-podcaster and advocate for Jewish representation, delves into the complexities of Jewish identity after the events of October 7. He shares insights on shifting voter dynamics, particularly among Gen Z Jews, and how political polarization impacts Jewish families. Platt discusses his nuanced stance on Israel, balancing support with criticisms of leaders, and emphasizes the need for joyful Jewish narratives in media. He reflects on the challenges of maintaining familial ties amid differing political views and the modern meaning of being Jewish.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Mamdani Reflects Youth Economic Frustration
- Jonah Platt sees Mamdani's win as limited, reflecting youth and economic frustration rather than a broad socialist wave.
- He emphasizes that young voters prioritized economic relief and charisma over foreign policy details like Israel positions.
Right-Wing Jewish Criticism Feels Like Betrayal
- Platt feels anti-Jewish attacks from non-Jews on the left mimic those from Jews on the left, but right-wing Jewish attacks feel like betrayal.
- He says criticism from fellow Jews on the right bothers him more because it's from his own
Middle Majority Identity
- Platt identifies as politically centrist and rejects full alignment with either major U.S. party due to mixed values and Israel positions.
- He targets the