

Why is our water sector broken?
Jun 18, 2025
Feargal Sharkey, an environmental campaigner passionate about rivers, joins Alistair Carmichael, Chair of the EFRA Committee, to tackle the crisis in the UK's water sector. They discuss alarming pollution levels and the shocking release of untreated sewage. Both highlight the need for industry reform, urgent accountability, and better ownership models to restore public trust. The conversation reveals how profit took precedence over environmental care, threatening both resources and consumer confidence, with looming financial burdens for households.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Passion Sparks Legal Challenge
- Feargal Sharkey's passion for fly fishing led him to protect polluted rivers and challenge the Environment Agency legally.
- This personal story sparked his deep involvement in water quality advocacy over several years.
Water Industry’s Failures Exposed
- Every river in England is polluted, largely due to failures by the water industry and regulators.
- Water companies have extracted vast sums for shareholders while infrastructure suffers and supplies risk running dry.
Commission’s Narrow Focus Disappoints
- The Independent Water Commission's interim report narrowly focuses on regulation and investment, falling short of promised industry-wide reform.
- This limited scope disappoints advocates expecting a full reset of the water sector.