Exploring Mormon Thought

027-The Relation of Moral Obligation and God in LDS Thought (Pt 1) - Ch 3

Oct 16, 2017
Explore the intriguing intersection of moral obligation and God, as Francis Beckwith's arguments are put under scrutiny. Delve into the complexities of meta-ethics in Mormon theology and how it contrasts with traditional views. The discussion unpacks the Euthyphro dilemma, questioning the relationship between God and moral truths. A fresh look at divine command theory reveals the nuances of moral freedom in the context of a morally perfect God. Plus, the importance of cultivating respectful dialogue in philosophical engagements is emphasized.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Meta-Ethics and Moral Obligation

  • Meta-ethics explores the basis for believing in objective moral obligations rather than the content of specific morals.
  • Traditional Christianity ties moral obligation directly to God's nature, whereas LDS views are challenged to explain this grounding.
INSIGHT

Beckwith's Critique of LDS Moral Grounding

  • Beckwith argues Mormonism's God can't ground moral law as God became God by following external moral laws.
  • Beckwith modifies divine command theory by grounding goodness in God's nature rather than commands, but this raises arbitrariness issues.
INSIGHT

Five Criteria for Moral Laws

  • Beckwith proposes five conditions any moral law must meet to be adequate.
  • He critiques LDS adoption of Platonism, social contract, and Aristotelian ethics as insufficient to ground moral obligation.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app