The Story Defining a woman
Apr 16, 2025
Helen Joyce, Director of Advocacy at Sex Matters and author of 'Trans: When Ideology Meets Reality,' delves into the implications of a recent Supreme Court ruling that defines women based on biological sex. She discusses the intricate balance between women's rights and transgender inclusion, highlighting controversies around women's support spaces. Joyce also navigates the contentious climate surrounding gender recognition laws, emphasizing grassroots activism and the ongoing debate in Scotland that confronts the core of feminism and gender identity.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Supreme Court Defines Woman Biologically
- The Supreme Court ruled that 'woman' in law refers to biological sex, confirming the Equality Act protects biological women.
- This ruling clarifies legal protections, rejecting that gender recognition certificates can redefine legal sex categories.
Conflicting UK Gender Laws
- The Gender Recognition Act (2004) and Equality Act (2010) created conflicting definitions of sex and gender.
- The 2010 Equality Act unintentionally blurred sex categories, letting some men be legally recognized as women, complicating sex-based rights.
Men Transferred to Women's Prisons
- The prison service transferred violent men identifying as women to women's prisons without legal gender recognition certificates.
- This practice disregarded biological sex and endangered women's safety by mixing male prisoners into female facilities.
