Jamie Tanna, a Senior Software Engineer at Elastic and co-maintainer of the OpenAPI2Go code generator, joins the conversation to dive deep into the world of APIs. He discusses the critical aspects of API design and the often-overlooked intricacies of versioning, including how to communicate breaking changes effectively. The role of documentation is emphasized, with Tanna advocating for a strategic approach to clarity and user experience. They also explore the complexity of HTTP status codes and the ongoing debate between XML and JSON in API interactions.
Versioning in APIs is essential for backward compatibility, as breaking changes can disrupt client applications if not communicated effectively.
Good API documentation is crucial for user understanding, requiring clear explanations beyond simple commands to enhance user experience and reduce friction.
Proper use of HTTP response codes is vital for communicating API call results, with standard conventions helping prevent confusion and enhance user interaction.
Deep dives
Understanding API Versioning
Versioning in APIs is crucial for maintaining backward compatibility while introducing new features. A breaking change can occur when a previously required field becomes optional or when the underlying behavior of an API changes. For example, if the process for onboarding a new user is altered significantly between versions, clients may encounter unexpected issues. Therefore, developers must communicate changes effectively, ensuring users understand the modifications and implications for their applications.
Communicating API Changes to Clients
Effective communication about version changes is essential to prevent disruption for clients using an API. Stacking numerous endpoints to accommodate new versions may appear practical but can complicate the understanding of which versions remain active. The challenge lies in informing clients about deprecations and the timeline for removing outdated endpoints. A potential approach involves establishing explicit contracts with clients, outlining their access and the duration support is guaranteed, prompting them to be proactive about updates.
Best Practices in API Documentation
Good API documentation is vital for user understanding and adoption. A common pitfall occurs when developers rely solely on single-letter command-line interface (CLI) options without providing sufficient documentation about their meanings. For clarity, it is beneficial to use long options in documentation, which aids users in grasping functionality without needing to refer to separate help texts. Providing clear, thorough documentation helps foster a better user experience and reduces friction when interacting with the API.
The Role of OpenAPI Specifications
OpenAPI specifications can significantly enhance API documentation and ensure that developers maintain a consistent understanding of how the API operates. However, many developers do not consistently keep these specifications updated, leading to a disconnect between the actual API and the documentation. Inadequate upkeep can cause confusion and hinder effective API usage. By embedding clear examples and adhering to the OpenAPI specification, developers can foster better understanding and usability of their APIs.
Handling HTTP Response Codes
Choosing appropriate HTTP response codes is integral to communicating the result of an API call. For instance, the debate around handling DELETE requests typically revolves around whether to return a 204, indicating no content, or a 404, indicating that the resource to delete was not found. Standard practices suggest that if a resource is deleted successfully, a status of 204 is appropriate, while a response of 404 can indicate a failed attempt due to the resource's absence. Ensuring that response codes align with standard expectations helps reduce confusion and improves user interactions with the API.
There are Web APIs everywhere, from the classic REST/HTTP, to GraphQL, to gRPC, we rely on them to get things done each and every day. But how much do we think about the design of these APIs? How do you document an API once you've created it? What even is versioning? Do we really understand HTTP? In this episode, Kris and the panel are joined by Jamie Tanna to discuss APIs, their design, how to document them, and more.
Want to hear us discuss APIs and how we design identifiers? Become a supporter and enjoy bonus content and higher quality audio today, and additional perks and benefits when we add them in the future.
