7am How the Catholic church fights abuse survivors
Nov 13, 2025
In this discussion, lawyer and advocate Judy Courtin, known for her dedication to representing survivors of child sexual abuse, tackles the High Court's controversial decision favoring the Catholic Church. She delves into the Church's claim of non-employment of priests and the resulting legal ramifications. Judy highlights the recent ACT legislation aimed at overturning this decision, emphasizing its significance for survivors. She critiques the Church's adversarial tactics and calls for swift legislative action across states to restore justice for victims.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
High Court Removed Vicarious Liability
- The High Court ruled priests and similar clergy are not in an employment relationship, removing vicarious liability for dioceses.
- Without negligence proved, many survivors now lack legal recourse against institutions.
Two Tiers Of Justice Emerged
- Byrd's outcome carved out volunteers and certain caregivers from accountability, creating unequal access to justice.
- Judy Courtin says this decision created a two-tier system where some survivors can sue and others cannot.
Church Strategy Prioritised Legal Defence
- Courtin argues the Church prioritised legal defence over compassion, treating survivors as commercial matters.
- She highlights the contrast with Catholic rhetoric about justice and mercy at Red Mass events.