Five Reasons You Shouldn’t Teach 'A Christmas Carol' This Year (Or Should You?)

In this episode of the Homeschool Better Together podcast, I’m joined by Dawn Garrett to chat about our special gift for homeschoolers this year—A Christmas Carol explorations! We’re offering a free resource full of fun activities, discussions, and enrichment to bring some holiday cheer into your homeschool. Dawn and I go over the history behind this yearly gift, why we’re excited about A Christmas Carol as this year's theme, and a few reasons you might not want to skip this one.

I share my journey of rediscovering the story’s true meaning and why it’s a perfect classic to enjoy as a family. We also talk about the Camp Christmas upgrade, packed with even more holiday fun, crafts, and planning resources to keep your homeschool cozy and memorable this season.

Key Points:

• A Christmas Carol explorations as a free holiday gift.
• Why this story offers valuable lessons in a family-friendly way.
• Optional Camp Christmas upgrade for extra activities, crafts, and planning tools.
• Fun community challenges and a chance to win prizes.

Resources and Links

• A Free Christmas Carol Explorations
• Dr. Anthony Esolen's Video on "A Christmas Carol"
• Skolay Sisters Podcast (Episode 46, "Don't Be the White Witch")
• Advent Morning Time Plans
• Christmas Celebration Morning Time Plans
• Homeschool Better Together Community 
• "A Christmas Carol" by Charles Dickens
• "10 Ways to Destroy the Imagination of Your Child" by Anthony Esolen
• "The Best Christmas Pageant Ever" by Barbara Robinson
• "The Muppet Christmas Carol" (Movie)
• Tim Curry's Narration of "A Christmas Carol" (Audiobook)
• Merry Beggars’ "A Christmas Carol" Radio Show
• Patrick Stewart performing "A Christmas Carol" (both as a single-person play and audiobook)

For full show notes and a transcript of today’s episode, head to pambarnhill.com/hsbt(25)

Mentioned in this episode:

Spring Curriculum Showcase – Fresh Deals Every Week at PamBarnhill.com!

Say goodbye to overwhelm and hello to joyful learning! The Spring Curriculum Showcase at PamBarnhill.com/shop is live, featuring weekly spotlights on our most-loved and brand-new resources for the 2025–2026 school year. Discover open-and-go language arts bundles, brand-new middle school resources, geography notebooks, a new photography course for teens, and more! Each week brings a new special you won't want to miss—shop now and find flexible, family-friendly curriculum that fits your real life.

Shop