Gilles Deleuze's 'Nietzsche & Philosophy': Chapter 2, "Active and Reactive" and Hierarchy
Sep 30, 2023
auto_awesome
French philosopher Gilles Deleuze discusses concepts from his text 'Nietzsche & Philosophy', including resentment, active and reactive forces, and hierarchy. They explore the transformative potential of reactive forces and the challenges of thinking in terms of individuals. The chapter also delves into the politics of becoming and the transformation of values within hierarchical systems.
Hierarchy in Nietzschean philosophy encompasses both an order of rank determining values and oppressive power dynamics.
The concept of active and reactive forces challenges a simplistic understanding of hierarchy and opens up new perspectives.
Deleuze emphasizes the importance of recognizing power asymmetries and resisting unjust forms of domination in hierarchies.
Deep dives
Hierarchy and Values in Nietzsche and Deleuze
Hierarchy plays a significant role in Nietzschean philosophy, as discussed in Deleuze's interpretation. However, it is crucial to understand the nuanced ways in which hierarchy is understood within this context. Deleuze distinguishes between two senses of hierarchy: one that pertains to an order of rank determining values, and one that is associated with oppressive power dynamics. The understanding of hierarchy as an order of rank is unavoidable in any system of values, even in a socialist vision that assigns moral importance to certain views and attitudes. On the other hand, oppressive power hierarchies that perpetuate inequalities and exploitation are actively challenged within the Nietzschean framework. By acknowledging power asymmetries and resisting unjust forms of dominations, Nietzsche's philosophy promotes a nuanced understanding of hierarchy that encompasses both the positive role it plays in value determination and the necessity to oppose unjust power dynamics.
Active and Reactive Forces in Nietzsche and Deleuze
The concept of active and reactive forces is essential in Nietzschean philosophy as interpreted by Deleuze. Active forces are characterized as plastic, dominant, and subjugating, while reactive forces are seen as utilitarian, adaptive, and often separating active forces from what they can do. Becoming active or reactive involves complex dynamics and is not a clear-cut binary. Nietzsche and Deleuze emphasize the importance of understanding the nuances of active and reactive forces, as well as the possibility of transformation and becoming active even for reactive forces. This notion challenges a simplistic understanding of hierarchy and provides room for reevaluation and reinterpretation of power dynamics. Ultimately, Deleuze's interpretation highlights the potential for active and reactive forces to transcend fixed and oppressive hierarchies and open up new perspectives and possibilities.
Hierarchy and Hierarchy
Hierarchy is a key concept discussed in Nietzsche and Deleuze's work, but it requires careful examination to grasp its implications fully. Deleuze distinguishes between two senses of hierarchy: one relating to an order of rank determining values, and the other associated with oppressive power dynamics. While the former cannot be entirely eradicated, as it is fundamental to any system of values, the latter is actively challenged within the Nietzschean framework. Rather than endorsing oppressive hierarchies, Nietzsche and Deleuze underscore the importance of recognizing power asymmetries and resisting unjust forms of domination. This nuanced understanding allows for a critical perspective on hierarchy's role in shaping social and political arrangements, prompting further exploration towards more equitable forms of power and value structures.
Understanding Hierarchy in Nietzsche and Deleuze
Hierarchy is a complex concept in Nietzschean philosophy, as elucidated by Deleuze's interpretation. Deleuze identifies two senses of hierarchy: one concerned with order of rank in determining values, and the other rooted in oppressive power dynamics. The former is intrinsic to any system of values and necessitates differentiation for value creation. However, the latter challenges fixed and oppressive hierarchies, emphasizing the need to recognize power asymmetries and resist unjust domination. Rather than promoting a simplistic view of hierarchy, Nietzsche and Deleuze's perspectives urge a nuanced understanding that acknowledges the multiplicity of power relations and seeks to challenge oppressive hierarchies.
Hierarchy and Power Dynamics in Nietzsche and Deleuze
Hierarchy is a fundamental idea explored in Nietzschean philosophy, as interpreted by Deleuze. Deleuze recognizes two aspects of hierarchy: one related to an order of rank that determines values, and one associated with oppressive power dynamics. While recognizing the inevitability of hierarchy in value determination, Nietzsche and Deleuze challenge egregious forms of hierarchy rooted in domination and exploitation. They emphasize the importance of understanding power asymmetries and resisting unjust power dynamics. The nuanced understanding of hierarchy allows for a critical stance toward oppressive structures, facilitating the exploration and establishment of more equitable and just power relations.
In this series of videos, we will highlight key themes from Gilles Deleuze's 1962 text 'Nietzsche & Philosophy'.
As mentioned in the discussion:
Ruggero Giuseppe Boscovich, "Theory of Natural Philosophy", https://archive.org/details/theoryofnaturalp00boscrich
This interview with Devin Goure (@LeftNietzschean) covers concepts in chapter 2 of 'Nietzsche & Philosophy', particularly reseentiment, bad conscience, active and reactive force, and hierarchy.
From August of 2023 until the end of the year, Acid Horizon is hosting reading group on 'Nietzsche & Philosophy'. Navigate to our Patreon page to find out more.
Support the podcast:
Linktree: https://linktr.ee/acidhorizon
Acid Horizon on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/acidhorizonpodcast
Zer0 Books and Repeater Media Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/zer0repeater
Merch: http://www.crit-drip.com
Order 'The Philosopher's Tarot': https://repeaterbooks.com/product/the-philosophers-tarot/
Subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts: https://tinyurl.com/169wvvhi
Happy Hour at Hippel's (Adam’s blog): https://happyhourathippels.wordpress.com