EP. 191: GEORGIA - The Child In The Trash Bag: The Disturbing Murder of Amari Hall
Feb 28, 2025
auto_awesome
Celeste Owens, partner of Brittany Hall, and Barbara Wright, Amari Hall's concerned grandmother, share insights into the heartbreaking case of 8-year-old Amari, whose body was found in a trash bag. They discuss the disturbing family dynamics that led to neglect and abuse, the investigation that exposed the flaws in child welfare, and the emotional turmoil surrounding Amari's tragic fate. Listeners hear about the complexities of truth, conflicting narratives during interrogations, and the urgent need for improved protective measures for at-risk children.
The investigation into Amari Hall's disappearance revealed alarming inconsistencies in her mother's account, sparking suspicion among law enforcement.
Amari and her siblings faced severe neglect and abuse in a chaotic living environment, highlighting systemic failures in child welfare.
Evidence gathered from Brittany Hall's phone, including videos of abuse, played a crucial role in unveiling the children's plight.
The court trials of Brittany Hall and Celeste Owens shed light on the grim realities of child abuse, provoking public outrage and reflection.
Deep dives
Disappearance of Amari Hall
On November 21, 2021, eight-year-old Amari Hall vanished from her hotel room in Gwinnett County, Georgia, while her mother, Brittany Hall, reported her missing after waking up to find the door ajar and Amari gone. Initial investigations saw multiple law enforcement agencies engage in a large-scale search, utilizing foot patrols, K-9 units, and helicopters, hoping to find the girl alive. However, doubts began to arise regarding Brittany's account when inconsistencies in timelines and behaviors emerged, raising suspicions among investigators. Sadly, their apprehensions were confirmed as the investigation revealed a pattern of abuse in Amari's life, ultimately leading to a tragic conclusion about her fate.
Brittany's Turbulent Relationship
Brittany Hall, a single mother, faced significant challenges in raising her three children, including Amari, whom she described as curious and intelligent. She moved back and forth between her mother Barbara's home and her own place, and after giving birth to her second and third children, she began a tumultuous relationship with Celeste Owens. The dynamic shifted as they all lived in a string of extended-stay hotels, often relying on inadequate resources for day-to-day survival. As isolation from her support system deepened, this unstable environment contributed to alarming neglect in the care of the children, with Brittany expressing disconcerting control over their lives.
The Signs of Neglect and Abuse
During their time at the hotel, Amari and her siblings endured extreme neglect, living in unhealthy and unsafe conditions while showing signs of abuse. Both children displayed noticeable physical cues of maltreatment, including bruises and signs of malnutrition, which lacked any reasonable explanation from Brittany and Celeste. Reports surfaced revealing that the Georgia Department of Human Services had previously investigated Brittany for potential neglect and abuse, although no concrete actions were taken at the time. This neglect escalated into horrific verbal and physical treatment of the children, culminating in a grave situation that police inadvertently uncovered.
Amari's Disappearance and Search Efforts
On the day of Amari's disappearance, Brittany alerted law enforcement claiming her daughter had gone missing overnight after going to bed safely. Initial efforts included detective interviews and a response team that reviewed surveillance footage from the hotel, which ironically showed no signs of Amari leaving her room. The inconsistencies from Brittany's narrative triggered further investigation into her behavior, revealing a troubling calm displayed during the search efforts, which raised more suspicion among the detectives. The extensive search and the procedure to find Amari were further complicated by the lies and evasions that Brittany and Celeste provided during the police inquiries.
The Grim Discovery
As investigations progressed, the search for Amari took a devastating turn, leading investigators to ascertain that she was likely dead. Evidence collected from Brittany's phone, including disturbing videos documenting the abuse of all three children, deepened the urgency to uncover Amari's whereabouts. Hours of interrogation yielded nothing concrete from Brittany or Celeste, with fluctuating claims of where Amari could be. Tragically, on November 23, 2021, investigators discovered Amari's body concealed in a trash bag within a wooded area, confirming the worst fears about her fate.
Charges Against Brittany and Celeste
Following the discovery of Amari's body, both Brittany Hall and Celeste Owens were arrested and faced multiple charges related to the horrific treatment of Amari and her siblings. Brittany was charged with felony child cruelty and concealing her daughter's death, while Celeste was charged with malice and felony murder, among other counts. As authorities unraveled the extent of the abuse, they uncovered significant evidence against both women, including testimony from Amari's younger siblings detailing the violence and mistreatment they endured. This evidence pointed to a history of physical and emotional cruelty that characterized their short lives.
The Trial and Its Impact
The trials of Brittany Hall and Celeste Owens highlighted the horrors of child abuse, capturing public attention with disturbing evidence caused by the wrongful actions of a caregiver. Both women attempted to downplay their involvement while delving into attempts to shift blame onto one another during the proceedings. Witness testimonies from the children further exposed the grim reality of their home life and painted a picture of enduring torment. After several days of harrowing missteps, the jury quickly returned a guilty verdict against Celeste, reflecting society’s strong disdain for the abuse endured by the children.
Sentencing and Reflecting on Amari's Life
In December 2024, Celeste Owens received a life sentence without the possibility of parole, alongside an additional 235 years for various charges related to Amari’s death and the abuse of her siblings. The court proceedings allowed the victims' family members to voice their grief and anger, emphasizing the profound impact her loss had on their lives. Amari’s tragic story served as a sobering reminder of the realities faced by some children, hidden in plain sight within dysfunctional family dynamics. As discussions of her life and abuse moved forward, local authorities and organizations were encouraged to address systemic issues regarding child welfare effectively.
In 2021, the body of a young 8-year-old girl named Amari Hall was found wrapped up in a trash bag in a wooded area in Gwinnett County, Georgia. But as investigators pieced together what had happened to her, at the hands of her mothers, an incredibly disturbing story began to unfold...
Join the Murder in America fam in our free Facebook Community for a behind-the-scenes look, more insights and current events in the true crime world: https://www.facebook.com/groups/4365229996855701
Feeling spooky? Follow Colin as he travels state to state (and even country to country!) investigating claims of extreme paranormal activity and visiting famous haunted locations on The Paranormal Files Official Channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/TheParanormalFilesOfficialChannel
