The Herd with Colin Cowherd Colin Cowherd Podcast - Pay Terry, Trade Parsons, Expectations For JJ McCarthy? Antonio Gates HoF Career, Why Undrafted Players Become Stars
Aug 4, 2025
John Middlekauff, host of the "3 and Out" podcast and NFL analyst, joins to share insights on player dynamics and contract negotiations. They discuss how J.J. McCarthy's success could parallel Brock Purdy's due to strong coaching and talent. The duo debates the contrasting strengths of the AFC and NFC and the expectations for the Chicago Bears. They also explore Antonio Gates' Hall of Fame journey and examine why undrafted players often achieve stardom in the NFL. Plus, Colin shares his newfound passion for golf!
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Talent and Coaching Elevate QBs
- J.J. McCarthy's success may parallel Brock Purdy's due to elite teammates and coaching.
- High-quality personnel elevate quarterbacks beyond their individual physical traits or draft status.
Underdog QBs Develop More
- Top NFL quarterbacks often come from less prestigious colleges because such programs demand they carry the team.
- Players from elite college teams may not have developed the same leadership or playmaking skills.
Prioritize Paying True Playmakers
- Teams should prioritize paying productive, underpaid players like Terry McLaurin to maintain loyalty.
- Overpaying on less reliable players can harm team chemistry and performance.