Top Scholar Explains How the Book of Mormon Was Created - The Mosiah Priority w/ Brent Metcalfe | Ep. 1971
Dec 11, 2024
auto_awesome
Brent Metcalfe, an influential LDS scholar and historian, shares insights from his extensive research on the Book of Mormon and reflects on his excommunication from the church. He reveals his groundbreaking discovery of the 'Mosiah Priority', suggesting a shifted timeline in the book's translation. The conversation dives into the authorship of the text, debates surrounding its historical context, and the emotional aftermath of excommunication, blending humor with serious analysis of faith, belief, and the complexities of religious narratives.
Brent Metcalf's excommunication from the LDS Church significantly influenced his journey in Mormon studies and pursuit of truth.
The conversation introduces the 'Mosiah priority theory', suggesting Joseph Smith translated the Book of Mosiah before Nephi, altering narrative interpretations.
Metcalf emphasizes the importance of analyzing historical context and discrepancies in the Book of Mormon to enhance understanding of its authenticity.
The podcast discusses the evolving nature of belief within the LDS community, advocating for a nuanced approach to personal spirituality and scholarship.
Listeners are encouraged to engage in open discussions about faith and history, fostering a shared journey towards understanding in Mormon studies.
Deep dives
Introduction of Guests
The episode features John DeLynn and his guests, including Brent Metcalf, a prominent LDS scholar and historian. DeLynn expresses excitement about having Metcalf on the show, highlighting his significance in Mormon studies. The conversation begins with a light tone, acknowledging the long-standing collaboration between DeLynn and his co-hosts. The episode marks a reunion, as Metcalf previously contributed to the Mormon Stories podcast, further underscoring his importance in the discussion.
Anniversary Milestone
DeLynn and the team reflect on the four-year anniversary of the Mormonism Live podcast, which coincided with their recording date. They celebrate the journey and growth the show has experienced since its inception in December 2020. This serves as a moment of gratitude for the audience, emphasizing the show's evolution and the collaborative efforts that have powered its success. DeLynn expresses pride in the work done alongside his co-hosts and mentions future plans for engagement.
Exploration of the Book of Mormon
DeLynn introduces the central theme of the episode, which revolves around the Book of Mormon and the implications of how it was produced. Metcalf shares insights and highlights the significance of his work, particularly regarding the translation process and the historical context surrounding it. They discuss how the narrative of the Book of Mormon has evolved over time, inviting the audience to consider both the faith-based perspective and the historical criticism it faces. The conversation unveils the importance of understanding these dimensions to appreciate the text more fully.
Brent Metcalf's Background
Metcalf provides a brief overview of his background, detailing his entry into Mormon studies and the impact of his prior work on the field. He recounts significant moments, including his excommunication from the LDS church, which occurred as a repercussion of his scholarship. DeLynn and Metcalf explore how this event, while painful, ultimately fueled Metcalf's pursuit of truth and understanding within the context of Mormon history. The unfolding narrative offers listeners a glimpse into Metcalf’s motivations and passion for the subject.
The Mosiah Priority Theory
The Mosiah priority theory emerges as a central topic in the conversation, examining the order in which the Book of Mormon was dictated. Metcalf explains that this theory suggests Joseph Smith translated the Book of Mosiah before Nephi, which has significant implications for understanding the text's coherence. They discuss how this perspective alters the framing of many passages within the Book of Mormon, emphasizing the need to reassess how readers approach the narrative. The discussion touches on historical context and the challenges posed by traditional interpretations.
The Role of Emma Smith
The episode raises the issue of Emma Smith's contributions to the translation process, particularly an anecdote regarding a moment of surprise related to the city of Jerusalem's walls. Metcalf highlights discrepancies in this narrative as barring further questions surrounding the authenticity and reliability of the accounts. The conversation delves into the implications of these anecdotes for understanding Joseph Smith's knowledge and intentions during the translation process. Ultimately, it encourages deeper examination of how narratives are constructed within religious contexts.
Historical Context and Analysis
Metcalf elaborates on the historical context of the Book of Mormon and the challenges scholars face in reconciling its claims with known historical facts. They discuss moments where the text references events or ideas that are inconsistent with the established timeline, further strengthening the case for the Mosiah priority theory. This segment underscores the importance of textual analysis and critical investigation for those seeking a deeper understanding of the Book of Mormon's authenticity. The implications of these discussions resonate throughout the episode.
Community and Belief
The conversation takes a reflective turn as they analyze the nature of belief and the community surrounding the LDS church. They examine the experiences of individuals who navigate their spirituality within the framework of evolving understanding, acknowledging both the challenges and comforts found in such paths. Metcalf advocates for a more nuanced approach to faith that accommodates personal experiences alongside textual studies and historical analysis. This examination fosters a sense of connection and encourages others to share their perspectives on spirituality.
Gratitude and Future Engagement
The episode concludes with an expression of gratitude for the audience's engagement and support. DeLynn and the team highlight the importance of continued exploration and discussion within the context of Mormon studies. The closing remarks encourage listeners to actively participate in conversations about faith, history, and community, inviting them to reflect on their journeys. The overall sentiment is one of inclusivity and openness, with a focus on fostering understanding and shared learning in the future.
Join us as we welcome scholar Brent Metcalfe for the 30th anniversary of his excommunication from the Mormon Church. We cover not only his excommunication but also his famous discovery of the “Mosiah First Priority” in the Book of Mormon translation.
00:08:00 New Approaches to the Book of Mormon00:10:25 Brent’s background00:16:50 Getting hired by Mark Hoffman00:25:00 Realizing the Book of Mormon was not historical00:31:30 How the Book of Mormon was created?00:34:10 A miracle book from God?00:46:55 Which essay are contained in the book and what they’re about01:01:40 Response to the book01:09:05 Negative review mocking Brent Metcalfe01:16:05 Questions for Brent Metcalfe01:24:30 Members who view the Book of MOrmon as historical? 01:32:50 How people maintain belief01:34:55 The Mosiah Priority01:38:20 The 600 year prophecy of Jesus’s coming01:46:00 The lost 116 pages01:52:29 Wall around Jerusalem02:01:30 Not depending on literary works02:08:55 Four main voices independent of Joseph Smith’s voice02:16:05 The title page to the Book of Mormon, no mention of the replacement text 02:17:55 Who knows the name of Jesus Christ?02:24:30 The writings of Malachi02:36:19 Picturing the golden plates02:44:12 Phone calls
Mormon Stories Thanks Our Generous Donors!
Help us continue to deliver quality content by becoming a donor today:
