How much can the upcoming vice presidential debate impact the election?
Sep 30, 2024
auto_awesome
Tamara Keith, NPR's senior White House correspondent, dives into the potential impact of the upcoming vice presidential debate on the 2024 election. She discusses historical influences of such debates and questions their relevance beyond theatrics. The conversation highlights challenges faced by candidates J.D. Vance and Tim Walz, as they tackle key issues like reproductive rights and healthcare. Keith emphasizes the importance of focusing on their presidential running mates to connect with voters effectively, rather than resorting to personal attacks.
The vice presidential debate offers a critical platform for candidates to contrast their views on pivotal issues like reproductive rights.
Historically, while vice presidential debates can influence public perception, they rarely result in decisive changes in election outcomes.
Deep dives
Debate Dynamics and Candidate Backgrounds
The upcoming vice presidential debate between J.D. Vance and Tim Walz presents an opportunity for both candidates to express their contrasting views on key issues affecting Americans. Both candidates boast small-town origins, with Vance hailing from Middletown, Ohio, and Walz from Butte, Nebraska, but their perspectives on topics such as reproductive rights showcase their ideological differences. In Minnesota, the emphasis is on protecting reproductive freedom, whereas in other regions, there is a strong focus on pro-life values, which may impact voter sentiments. As they engage in this 90-minute debate on a highly competitive election stage, their performance could be significant in shaping public perception and the broader narrative of the campaign.
Significance of Past Vice Presidential Debates
Historically, vice presidential debates have often been viewed as moments of political theater rather than pivotal turning points in election outcomes. For instance, the memorable exchange between Dan Quayle and Lloyd Benson in 1988 highlighted a powerful moment that ultimately did not alter the election results. Experts suggest that while these debates can introduce candidates to the public and potentially influence voter opinions, they rarely swing the race decisively. The roles of these candidates become crucial, especially when their running mates are older and questions about succession arise, as voters need reassurance about their ability to step up if necessary.
Anticipated Challenges and Strategies
The debate poses unique challenges for both candidates, particularly in articulating the policies of their respective running mates. J.D. Vance will need to navigate questions surrounding Donald Trump's policy positions and how they would be implemented, given the lack of specificity often associated with Trump. On the other hand, Tim Walz must clarify the emerging policies of Vice President Harris, who is still in the process of establishing her platform. As they prepare, both candidates must focus on addressing their opponents' policies while also ensuring that the spotlight remains on the presidential candidates.
In a race where so much of the polling is within the margin of error — it seems as though any one thing could affect the outcome of the 2024 presidential election.
But have vice presidential debates made a difference in past races?
NPR's senior White House Correspondent Tamara Keith dug into that existential, and political question.
For sponsor-free episodes of Consider This, sign up for Consider This+ via Apple Podcasts or at plus.npr.org.