discussion between Danny and Matthew Hoh, about former U.S. President Donald Trump's approach to the Russia-Ukraine war, European reactions, and broader geopolitical dynamics.

Key points:

Trump’s Negotiations with Putin: Trump is engaging with Vladimir Putin and considering negotiations to end the Russia-Ukraine war, which has caused panic among European leaders and opposition from U.S. foreign policy elites.

European Reaction: The commentators express surprise that European leaders and policymakers are caught off guard by Trump’s approach, despite his long-standing signals about wanting to de-escalate U.S. involvement.

Opposition from U.S. Establishment: Figures like John Bolton and H.R. McMaster criticize Trump, arguing that engaging in negotiations is akin to surrendering to Putin.

Ukraine’s NATO Membership: The discussion highlights that NATO membership for Ukraine was never a realistic option, as key European nations (Germany, France, UK) had privately indicated opposition even before the war.

Russia’s War Aims: They argue that Russia is not aiming for European conquest but seeks a neutral Ukraine and strategic security guarantees.

Criticism of U.S. Policy: The speakers criticize what they see as Washington’s rigid, imperialistic mindset, arguing that U.S. policies have inadvertently strengthened ties between Russia, China, and Iran.

Potential for a Grand Deal: They speculate that Trump’s negotiations could lead to a broader settlement, including strategic arms reductions and shifting global alliances.

Overall, the speech presents a skeptical view of the Western narrative on Russia, challenges mainstream foreign policy assumptions, and suggests Trump’s approach could lead to a major geopolitical realignment.

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Daf Yomi Shabbos Daf 10 by R’ Eli Stefansky