The Audio Long Read The origins of today’s conflict between American Jews over Israel
4 snips
Oct 20, 2025 American Jews' evolving relationship with Israel is explored, revealing early cultural fascinations and political divides. The Six-Day War of 1967 stands out as a transformative moment, uniting many in emotional solidarity. Yet, critiques emerged, highlighting tensions over identity and dual loyalties. The shift from skepticism to advocacy reshaped American Jewish institutions, prompting questions about representation and territorial expansion. The podcast delves into historical perspectives that continue to influence contemporary debates.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Postwar Shift Toward Zionism
- Zionism's American shift accelerated during and after WWII, turning non-Zionist institutions toward support for a Jewish state.
- The establishment of Israel in 1948 weakened organized anti-Zionism and reshaped American Jewish politics.
Dissent Was Marginalized
- Critics like William Zuckerman warned that uncritical identification with Israel risked fueling anti-Semitism and moral compromises.
- His dissent was marginalized and often labeled as self-hatred or treason by pro-Israel forces.
Ben-Gurion vs Blaustein Clash
- David Ben-Gurion publicly urged American Jews to emigrate and criticized comfortable Western Jewish life as a decline into assimilation.
- Jacob Blaustein angrily defended American Jewish identity and insisted American Jews were not in exile.
