The Opinions David Brooks, E.J. Dionne and Robert Siegel Take Stock of 2025
44 snips
Dec 18, 2025 
This discussion features David Brooks, an Opinion columnist known for his cultural and political insights, and E.J. Dionne Jr., a political analyst focusing on civic life. They dive into Trump’s political landscape, assessing his waning influence and moderates' exodus over affordability concerns. The trio explores the national mood of anxiety, the duality of AI's potential, and the ongoing housing crisis. They also address rising anti-Semitism and its implications, before wrapping up with cultural highlights that bring them joy.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Trump: Decay Without Fracture
- David Brooks sees decline, not collapse, in Trump's standing and expects continued rule-breaking power.
- He calls the moment decay rather than fracture, noting Trump will keep exercising power while ignoring restraints.
Reasonable Voters Drift From Trump
- E.J. Dionne argues many Trump voters were pragmatic and are now moving away over affordability and perceived elite indifference.
- He likens recent shifts to Biden's Afghanistan moment and warns Trump could still rebound.
Cultural Pessimism Shapes Politics
- Robert Siegel and David Brooks highlight national anxiety and cultural pessimism as central forces shaping politics.
- Brooks notes negative language now exceeds positive usage, marking a historic cultural shift.