Brink Lindsey, formerly of the Cato Institute, talks about governmental capacity and making it better. They discuss the negative effects of policies that redistribute wealth, occupational licensing, and intellectual property debate. They also explore the challenges of consolidating pension funds in Illinois and the consequences of ideologies on governing capacity.
Government legitimacy should be based on effective and accountable governance, emphasizing real outcomes.
Deep dives
The Challenge of Government Inefficiency
The podcast episode discusses the challenge of government inefficiency and the need to improve the efficiency of governance. It highlights how ideological beliefs on both the right and left have contributed to the lack of effective government action. On the right, a suspicion and hostility toward government has led to a toxic and unproductive view of the public sector. On the left, a libertarian turn has emphasized second-guessing government decisions in the name of the public interest, resulting in a gridlock of governance. This ideological clash has hindered progress in areas like climate change policy and infrastructure development. The episode suggests that a shift in mindset is needed, away from a focus on procedural regularity and toward effective and accountable governance.
Barriers to Effective Climate Change Policy
The podcast episode highlights the challenges in implementing effective climate change policies. It discusses the importance of a carbon tax strategy in achieving environmental goals, but acknowledges the difficulty of gaining public support for such measures. The episode emphasizes the need for collective action in promoting innovation, as simply imposing costs within the system may not be sufficient. It also examines the role of government subsidies in driving down costs and promoting clean energy technologies. However, it acknowledges the regulatory challenges and bottlenecks that hinder the progress of climate change initiatives, particularly in areas like land use policies and infrastructure development.
Recognizing the Need for Decisive Governance
The podcast episode calls for a reconception of government legitimacy rooted in effective and accountable governance. It critiques the bureaucratic procedures and a 'process fetish' that prioritize procedural regularity over governing successfully in the public interest. The episode highlights the importance of having decision-makers who can make trade-offs between various interests and make accountable decisions. It suggests that areas like government use of information technology could serve as a starting point for demonstrating the success and effectiveness of a rethinking of governance. Overall, the episode emphasizes the need for a shift in mindset and a focus on achieving real outcomes in governance.
The Challenges in Land Use Policies and Infrastructure Development
The podcast episode discusses the challenges in land use policies and infrastructure development. It points out the difficulties in navigating the maze of state, local, and federal permitting requirements, particularly in building renewable energy infrastructure. The episode highlights the need for a restructuring of decision-making processes to include the right mix of stakeholders and to enable trade-offs between competing interests. It also emphasizes the need to overcome regulatory hurdles and bottlenecks that inflate costs and induce delays. The example of high-speed rail is mentioned to illustrate the larger problem of bureaucratic inefficiency and the inability to make decisive decisions.
The Importance of Collaboration and Accountability
The podcast episode underscores the importance of collaboration and accountability in governing effectively. It highlights the need to overcome ideological divisions that hinder government action and progress. The episode emphasizes the value of collaboration between different political persuasions, as demonstrated by the book 'The Captured Economy' and other efforts. It calls for a reconception of government legitimacy based on actual governance outcomes and the ability to make accountable decisions. Furthermore, the episode stresses the need to trust individuals to make decisions and holds them responsible for those decisions.
Our first lifeboat is hope — hope that government could actually do good. Brink Lindsey, formerly of the Cato Institute, and now Director of the Open Society Project at the Niskanen Center, talks to me about governmental capacity, and how we could make it better.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode