Bulwark Takes

Democrats Aren’t Winning Because They’re Brilliant. It’s Trump.

10 snips
Oct 9, 2026
Russ Muirhead, Dartmouth democracy professor; Sam Stein, political journalist; and Lis Smith, veteran Democratic strategist, debate Trump’s declining fortunes and the GOP’s nationalist future under JD Vance. They explore why Democrats need persuasion, broader coalitions, authentic candidates, and non-demagogic populism. They also consider local political courage, the wide-open 2028 race, and how Trump might act if he loses Congress.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Democrats Need Persuasion Beyond Mobilization

  • Democrats have over-relied on mobilizing their base instead of persuading voters beyond it.
  • Lis Smith argues a House or Senate majority requires a big-tent party where candidates can differ across regions and issues.
INSIGHT

Trump May Win Democrats Their Majority

  • Tim Miller expects many Democrats to benefit primarily from Trump's mistakes and deeply unpopular political environment.
  • He warns Democrats not to mistake midterm gains for proof that their presidential strategy is working.
INSIGHT

Trump Is Masking Democratic Weaknesses

  • Sam Stein says Trump's disastrous performance can temporarily neutralize structural disadvantages that often hurt Democrats.
  • He compares the moment with 2020, when extraordinary crises still produced only a narrow Biden victory.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app