The Trouble with Consciousness (Mark Delp and Esme Partridge)
Jun 1, 2024
auto_awesome
Neuroscientist Mark Delp and philosopher Esme Partridge discuss the complexities of consciousness, delving into historical studies, Aquinas' perspective, and the quest for truth. They explore consciousness as more than awareness, emphasizing its dynamic nature and its role in transforming individuals through religion.
Understanding consciousness should focus on outlier experiences rather than a stable norm.
Deep dives
Current Understanding of Consciousness
The current discourse on consciousness includes two main contexts, one in new age spirituality and the other in technology and AI. Mark Delp critiques the prevailing narrative on consciousness, highlighting its lack of clarity and definition. He contrasts the common view of consciousness as awareness with a more intricate understanding, emphasizing the historical perspectives on consciousness that delve deeper into the nature of the mind.
Evolution of Interest in Consciousness
The interest in consciousness surged in the late 19th century due to behaviors observed through brain experiments, leading to the recognition of consciousness as a distinct entity deserving dedicated research. Mark's theory links this emergence to behavioral manipulations showing outlier aspects of consciousness. He notes a shift towards defining consciousness based on outlier experiences rather than a stable norm.
Aquinas' View on Consciousness and Affect
Aquinas' perspective on consciousness emphasizes the integral role of affect in consciousness, going beyond mere awareness to include emotional responses and sentient experiences. He views consciousness as a joint function of the mind and the will, highlighting the affective aspect as essential for a comprehensive understanding of consciousness. Aquinas' approach merges philosophical and psychological dimensions, embracing affect as a significant component of consciousness.
Consciousness and Relationship to Reality
Consciousness extends beyond mere awareness to entail a continuous and active process of discernment and judgment, reflecting a deep engagement with the world. Aquinas posits consciousness as a means to perceive universal truths and identify eternal categories, emphasizing a natural inclination to seek truth and correspond with objective reality. This orientation towards discernment underscores the intimate connection between consciousness, moral sense, and the innate pursuit of truth.