Chris McGreal, a seasoned writer for The Guardian US, shares his insights on South African politics and history. He discusses Trump's controversial executive orders regarding South Africa, particularly the focus on white Afrikaners and land reform. McGreal critiques Trump's simplistic views versus the complex realities of post-apartheid issues. The conversation also explores the role of figures like Elon Musk in shaping these narratives, including their business interests and the implications for economic equity in South Africa.
Trump's decision to cut aid and offer asylum to South Africa's Afrikaners highlights a simplistic understanding of the region's complex racial dynamics.
Influential figures from Silicon Valley, like Elon Musk, are shaping U.S. policy discussions around South Africa by intertwining personal business interests with racial narratives.
Deep dives
Trump's Executive Order on South Africa
An executive order signed by U.S. President Donald Trump to cut financial assistance to South Africa is generating significant discussion. The order controversially offers political asylum to the Afrikaner population, a move that raises eyebrows given the reduced asylum options for many in other countries. This action stems from Trump’s long-standing concern over what he perceives as the persecution of white farmers, drawing parallels to historical events in Zimbabwe. Analysts suggest that this reflects a simplistic view of the complex socio-political landscape in South Africa, highlighting ongoing tensions around land ownership and racial dynamics.
Misinformation Surrounding Land Expropriation
The introduction of the Expropriation Act in South Africa, which allows government land acquisition without compensation under specific circumstances, has fueled debates on racial equity. This law aims to address historical imbalances, as white South Africans hold over 70% of land despite making up only 7% of the population. Misinformation propagated by Afrikaner organizations has led to claims of a racial conspiracy against whites, despite legislative efforts intended to correct past injustices. Observers note that while the law is intended to balance land ownership, most white farmers are not in immediate danger of losing their land, indicating that the narrative being shaped may be exaggerated.
The Role of the PayPal Mafia in U.S.-South Africa Relations
Key figures from Silicon Valley, often referred to as the PayPal Mafia, are influencing the political landscape concerning South Africa. Prominent individuals like Elon Musk, Peter Thiel, and David Sachs, who have ties to South Africa, advocate for policies that align with their business interests, notably around Musk's Starlink project. As these influencers voice support for claims of discrimination against white South Africans, they simultaneously work to navigate local laws requiring black ownership in enterprises. This intersection of business interests and racial politics exemplifies how personal backgrounds can shape narratives in contemporary U.S. policy discussions.
Among his recent executive orders, Donald Trump moved to halt aid to South Africa over a land law and extended political asylum to South Africa’s white Afrikaner population.
Where does Trump’s seemingly spotty understanding of South Africa come from? How could having close advisors who grew up in apartheid-era South Africa, like Elon Musk, influence him?
Guest: Chris McGreal, writer for The Guardian US who reported from South Africa during the end of apartheid.
Want more What Next? Join Slate Plus to unlock full, ad-free access to What Next and all your other favorite Slate podcasts. You can subscribe directly from the What Next show page on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Or, visit slate.com/whatnextplus to get access wherever you listen.
Podcast production by Elena Schwartz, Paige Osburn, Anna Phillips, Madeline Ducharme, Rob Gunther, and Ethan Oberman.