Making Sense with Sam Harris

#258 — The Fall of Afghanistan

5 snips
Aug 23, 2021
Peter Bergen, author and national security analyst, dives into the chaos following the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan. He critiques the fall of the Afghan military and the resurgence of the Taliban, questioning America's ethical responsibilities towards Afghan allies. The conversation touches on bin Laden's rise within al-Qaeda and the complexities of global jihadism. Bergen also dissects the historical narratives around the Taliban and their relationship with ISIS, emphasizing the nuanced dynamics shaping modern terrorism.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Neo-Isolationism

  • A neo-isolationist consensus is forming on the far left and right regarding the US involvement in Afghanistan.
  • Both sides believe the US had no business being there, but for different reasons, denigrating either Afghans or America.
INSIGHT

Flawed Withdrawal

  • The US withdrawal from Afghanistan, even if planned perfectly, was a flawed decision.
  • The Taliban's return to power poses a threat to Afghan citizens and potentially emboldens global jihadist movements.
INSIGHT

Legitimate Intervention

  • The initial US intervention in Afghanistan after 9/11 was legitimate.
  • Maintaining a US troop presence, despite challenges, was arguably better than the current outcome.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app