ICYMI: A Former School Shooter is a TikTok Star. Should He Even Be Allowed Online?
Oct 25, 2023
auto_awesome
Former school shooter turned mental health reform advocate, Jon Romano, discusses his controversial presence on TikTok and the possibility of redemption for those who commit violent acts. Dr. Teiahsha Bankhead, an expert in restorative and racial justice, joins the conversation to explore restorative justice principles as an alternative to punitive approaches.
Former school shooter, Jon Romano, has gained a following on TikTok as he advocates for gun safety and mental health reform.
Dr. Teiahsha Bankhead emphasizes the importance of a restorative justice process in holding individuals accountable and facilitating their recovery.
Deep dives
John Romano: From School Shooter to TikTok Advocate
John Romano, a former school shooter, has gained a following on TikTok as he advocates for gun safety and mental health reform. In 2004, at the age of 16, Romano brought a shotgun to his high school in upstate New York, firing multiple shots and injuring a teacher. He pleaded guilty to attempted murder and reckless endangerment, serving 17 years in prison. Following his release in 2020, Romano began using TikTok to share his experiences in prison, promote gun reform, and discuss preventing school shootings. His presence on TikTok has sparked debates about whether someone with his history should have a public platform. Critics argue that Romano should not be allowed to monetize his crimes or claim victimhood, while others believe that his firsthand perspective could be valuable in deterring future acts of violence. The question remains whether ex-convicts who committed violent acts should be allowed to have public platforms and how social media can play a role in their healing and transformation.
The Role of Restorative Justice and Healing
Dr. Tia Şabančet, an expert in restorative justice, discusses the potential for healing and transformation for individuals who have caused harm. Dr. Şabančet emphasizes the importance of a restorative justice process in holding individuals accountable and facilitating their recovery. She believes that individuals who have committed violent acts can play a crucial role in deterring future violence by sharing their experiences. However, she acknowledges the need for caution regarding the monetization and glorification of tragedy on social media platforms. Dr. Şabančet suggests that a comprehensive support system, including therapy, counseling, and community circles, could aid in the healing and transformative journey of individuals like John Romano.
The Public Response and Calls for Accountability
The public response to John Romano's TikTok presence has been mixed, with many expressing anger and concern. Some users argue that Romano should not be given a platform or be allowed to profit from his crimes. They question his motives and label him as a narcissist. Others, however, see a potential for change and want to engage with Romano's perspective, believing that he can provide valuable insights to prevent future acts of violence. The debate raises broader questions about the boundaries of free speech, the role of social media platforms, and how accountability can be achieved while promoting healing and transformation.
Navigating Complexity and Finding Solutions
The complexity of John Romano's case highlights the need for nuanced discussions and comprehensive approaches. Dr. Şabančet suggests that rather than exiling individuals like Romano from social platforms, efforts should focus on promoting reflection, transformation, and accountability. A restorative justice process, including circles of support and accountability, could facilitate this journey. However, she also emphasizes the responsibility of individuals to critically engage with social media content, cultivating an educated and mindful approach that prioritizes health, healing, and understanding.
On today’s episode, Rachelle Hampton and Candice Lim dive into the saga of Jon Romano. At the age of 16, Romano walked into his high school with a shotgun in an attempt, he says, to commit law-enforcement-assisted suicide. Though no one was killed in the ensuing violence, a teacher was shot and injured. Romano pled guilty to attempted murder and reckless endangerment. He served 17 years in prison and was released in 2020. Since his release, he’s been a public advocate for mental health reform and gun control. Since 2022, TikTok has been a part of that advocacy work for Romano, a choice that landed Romano in the headlines once again after many decried his public platform of more than 275,000 followers.
Romano’s presence on TikTok and his large public profile raise thorny questions around the possibility of redemption and life online for those who commit violent acts. To help answer those questions, Hampton and Lim are joined by Dr. Teiahsha Bankhead, the executive director of Restorative Justice for Oakland Youth and an expert in restorative and racial justice.
This podcast is produced by Se’era Spragley Ricks, Daisy Rosario, Rachelle Hampton and Candice Lim.