Brad Setser, a senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations and trade expert, breaks down Trump’s sweeping tariffs and their historical impact on U.S. trade policy. He highlights how the tariffs aim to tackle border security but may worsen the illegal drug trade. Setser explains the complexities of trade relations with China, Mexico, and Canada, and the adverse effects on American manufacturing and jobs. The conversation reveals the challenges of using tariffs as a foreign policy tool and questions their overall effectiveness in restoring U.S. industries.
Trump's tariffs aim to boost domestic production while potentially exacerbating illegal drug trafficking and consumer prices.
The historical context of U.S. tariffs reflects a shift from low tariffs for free trade to protective measures addressing trade imbalances, particularly with China.
Deep dives
Trump's Tariff Strategy and Economic Impact
Donald Trump has adopted a strong tariff-centric approach to American trade, aiming to bolster domestic production and mitigate perceived economic threats from imports, particularly from China. By implementing tariffs on imported goods, Trump believes that American-made products will become more competitive, encouraging companies to establish factories within the U.S. This strategy reflects a significant shift from the past fifty years of generally low tariffs, which were intended to promote free trade and economic interdependence. However, the application of tariffs as an economic tool can lead to higher prices for consumers and has raised questions regarding their effectiveness in truly revitalizing American manufacturing.
Tariffs as Foreign Policy Tools
The current use of tariffs under Trump’s administration demonstrates a unique application of trade policy as a means of influencing foreign relations, particularly concerning immigration and drug trafficking issues. Unlike traditional tariffs that aim primarily at economic outcomes, these recent tariffs are viewed as instruments for achieving geopolitical objectives, such as reducing the flow of illegal substances. This unconventional use of tariffs may have unintended consequences, potentially worsening the situations they intend to address by triggering economic hardships in the affected nations. Critics argue that utilizing tariffs in this manner could prove ineffective and create broader tensions rather than resolve specific trade disputes.
Historical Context of Tariffs in America
The historical context of tariffs in the United States reveals that their prominence has fluctuated significantly over time, particularly from the 1860s until the 1930s, when they served as a primary source of government revenue. The post-World War II era marked a departure from this trend, as low and falling tariffs became the norm, largely to foster stronger international trade relations and prevent the economic isolation seen during the Great Depression. As nations became more interconnected, a consensus emerged on the benefits of trade among allies, leading to policies that encouraged open markets and minimized tariff barriers. However, more recent developments, including the rise of China as a global economic powerhouse, have reignited concerns over the effects of trade imbalances and the necessity for protective measures.
Trade Agreements and Manufacturing Shifts
Debates surrounding trade agreements like NAFTA highlight the complex dynamics of trade relationships, particularly their influence on American manufacturing and worker wages. While NAFTA facilitated increased trade with Mexico, concerns have been raised about its impact on certain industries within the U.S., especially the auto sector. Nevertheless, economic studies suggest that the real disruptions in American manufacturing are more closely linked to China's entry into the World Trade Organization than to trade with Mexico, as China's trade has historically been unbalanced, leading to significant job losses in competing sectors. This ongoing discourse emphasizes the need to analyze trade policies critically and implement measures that both protect American workers and acknowledge the complexities of global trade interdependence.
President Donald Trump is implementing sweeping tariffs to ostensibly tighten border security and crack down on the fentanyl trade. The moves include a 25 percent tariff on all steel and aluminum imports, blanket 10 percent tariffs on Chinese imports, and potentially steep tariffs on Mexican and Canadian goods. These actions could have monumental consequences for the global economy.
Today on Lever Time, senior podcast producer Arjun Singh sits down with economist Brad Setser to discuss the history of tariffs, the complexity of the United States' trade relationships with Canada, Mexico, and China, and how the effects of these tariffs could potentially make the illegal drug trade worse. Setser was a senior adviser to the U.S. Trade Representative and writes about China’s export economy in his newsletter Follow the Money.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode