Church History Matters cover image

Church History Matters

038 How Can We Think Like Historians?

Nov 21, 2023
Learn how historians evaluate the reliability of historical claims and the importance of being source critical. They emphasize the significance of firsthand accounts and discuss the dangers of biased narratives. The hosts analyze witness accounts and allegations of adultery involving Joseph Smith. Stay tuned for an upcoming episode on evaluating historical statements.
57:47

Podcast summary created with Snipd AI

Quick takeaways

  • Proximity of the source, time elapsed, and motives should be considered when evaluating historical claims.
  • Comparing accounts and examining supporting evidence are important in assessing the reliability of historical claims.

Deep dives

Evaluation of Historical Claims

When evaluating historical claims and assertions, it is important to consider several factors. First, the proximity of the source to the actual event is crucial. In the case of William McClellan's letter, it is a secondhand account of a conversation between Emma Smith and McClellan that allegedly took place in 1847, recalling an incident from 1836. Second, the time that has passed before recording the account raises concerns about accuracy. McClellan's letter was written in 1872, around 25 years after the conversation he claims to have had. Third, examining the motives of the person sharing the account is essential. McClellan had a contentious relationship with the Church and may have had ulterior motives to discredit Joseph Smith. Fourth, considering the factual basis versus opinion is important. McClellan's account is highly opinionated and lacks corroboration from other sources. Fifth, comparing the account with other sources reveals a lack of consistency and supporting evidence. Other sources do not mention the specific incident described by McClellan. Overall, given the distance in time, the questionable motives, and lack of corroboration, this historical claim should be approached with caution and skepticism.

Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts

Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
App store bannerPlay store banner